Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /184 of 196

Combinatorics Difficulty 6.7 National Olympiad Prove it Soviet Union

Problem:
Given nn odd and a set of integers {a1}\{a_1\}, {a2}\{a_2\}, ..., {an}\{a_n\}, derive a new set ({a1}+{a2})/2(\{a_1\} + \{a_2\}) / 2, ({a2}+{a3})/2(\{a_2\} + \{a_3\}) / 2, ..., ({an1}+{an})/2(\{a_{n - 1}\} + \{a_n\}) / 2, ({an}+{a1})/2(\{a_n\} + \{a_1\}) / 2. However many times we repeat this process for a particular starting set we always get integers. Prove that all the numbers in the starting set are equal.

For example, if we started with 5,9,15, 9, 1, we would get 7,5,37, 5, 3, and then 6,4,56, 4, 5, and then 5,4,5,5.55, 4, 5, 5.5. The last set does not consist entirely of integers.

Solution

Solution:
Let the smallest value be ss and suppose it occurs mm times (with m<nm < n). Then the values in the next stage are all at least ss, and at most m1m - 1 equal ss. So after at most mm iterations the smallest value is increased.

We can never reach a stage where all the values are equal, because if (a1+a2)/2=(a2+a3)/2==(an1+an)/2=(an+a1)/2(a_1 + a_2) / 2 = (a_2 + a_3) / 2 = \ldots = (a_{n - 1} + a_n) / 2 = (a_n + a_1) / 2, then a1+a2=a2+a3a_1 + a_2 = a_2 + a_3 and hence a1=a3a_1 = a_3. Similarly, a3=a5a_3 = a_5, and so a1=a3=a5==ana_1 = a_3 = a_5 = \ldots = a_n (nn odd). Similarly, a2=a4==an1a_2 = a_4 = \ldots = a_{n - 1}. But we also have an+a1=a1+a2a_n + a_1 = a_1 + a_2 and so a2=ana_2 = a_n, so that all aia_i are equal. In other words, if all the values are equal at a particular stage, then they must have been equal at the previous stage, and hence at every stage.

Thus if the values do not start out all equal, then the smallest value increases indefinitely. But that is impossible, because the sum of the values is the same at each stage, and hence the smallest value can never exceed (a1++an)/n(a_1 + \ldots + a_n) / n.

Note that for nn even the argument breaks down because a set of unequal numbers can iterate into a set of equal numbers. For example: 1,3,1,3,,1,31, 3, 1, 3, \ldots, 1, 3.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.