The numbers S1=22, S2=24, …, Sn=22n are given. A rectangle OABC is constructed on the Cartesian plane according to these numbers. For this, starting from the point O the points A1,A2,…,An are consistently marked along the axis Ox, and the points C1,C2,…,Cn are consistently marked along the axis Oy in such a way that for all k from 1 to n the lengths of the segments Ak−1Ak=xk and Ck−1Ck=yk are positive integers (let A0=C0=O, An=A and Cn=C) and xk⋅yk=Sk.
a) Find the maximal possible value of the area of the rectangle OABC and all pairs of sets (x1,x2,…,xn) and (y1,y2,…,yn) at which this maximal area is reached.
b) Find the minimal possible value of the area of the rectangle OABC and all pairs of sets (x1,x2,…,xn) and (y1,y2,…,yn) at which this minimal area is reached.
Solution
Answer:
a) The maximal possible value of area equals 31(4n−1)(4n+n−1) and it is attained at sets (1,1,…,1,22n) and (22,24,…,22n−2,1).
b) The minimal possible value equals 4(2n−1)2 and it is attained in two cases: either the sets xi and yi equal (22,23,…,2n+1) and (20,21,…,2n−1) or both sets equal (21,22,…,2n).
Since the lengths xi and yj are divisors of the given numbers, the total amount of sets is finite, so there exist the minimal area of the rectangle OABC. We will prove the following
Lemma. The area of the rectangle OABC is maximal if and only if the next two conditions hold:
1) For each i from 1 to n either xi or yi equals 1;
2) The difference ∣(x1+x2+⋯+xn)−(y1+y2+⋯+yn)∣ is minimal among all sets, satisfying condition 1).
Proof of the lemma. Take sets (x1,x2,…,xn) and (y1,y2,…,yn) such that the area of the rectangle OABC is maximal.
First we prove the necessity of the first condition. Suppose there exists k such that both xk and yk are greater than 1. Denote x1+x2+⋯+xn=X, X−xk=Xk, y1+y2+⋯+yn=Y and Y−yk=Yk. Then the area of the rectangle OABC equals S=XY=(Xk+xk)(Yk+yk). Without loss of generality let Xk≥Yk. Replace in the sets (xi) and (yi) the lengths xk and yk by 1 and Sk, respectively. The area of the new rectangle equals S′=(Xk+1)(Yk+Sk). The difference between new and old areas equals
Now we prove the necessity of the second condition. The first condition implies
X+Y=S1+S2+⋯+Sn+n.
This sum depends only on the given values S1,S2,…,Sn, denote this sum by C. The area of the rectangle OABC equals S=XY=X(C−X), which is the quadratic polynomial of the variable X. The corresponding parabola is opened to the bottom and the abscissa of its vertex equals C/2 (which corresponds X=Y). Hence the area of the rectangle is maximal when X is closest to C/2, which is equivalent to the minimality of ∣X−Y∣.
To prove the sufficiency of the conditions 1) and 2) note that for all sets satisfying these conditions the values of X and Y are the same (up to permutation), hence they all provide the maximal value of the area. The lemma is proved.
Proceed to the solution of a). Since 22n=1+20+21+⋯+22n−1, we have
22n>22+24+⋯+22n−2,
whence the conditions of the lemma are satisfied if and only if one set equals (1,1,…,1,22n) while the second set equals (22,24,…,22(n−1),1). Wherein the maximal possible area of the rectangle equals 31(4n−1)(4n+n−1). Thus, a) is finished.
To find the minimal possible area, we use the Cauchy-Bunyakovsky inequality
If there exist at least one pair of sets (xi) and (yi) at which this inequality is the equality, then the last expression provides the minimal possible area. Moreover, then this minimal value is attained only for such sets (xi) and (yi). The Cauchy-Bunyakovsky inequality turns into the equality if and only if y1x1=y2x2=⋯=ynxn. Since x1y1=S1=4, there exist the three variants: x1=4, y1=1; x1=1, y1=4; and x1=y1=2. First two variants give the pair (22,23,…,2n+1) and (20,21,…,2n−1) of sets, and the third variant gives two sets equal (21,22,…,2n). Both cases provide the minimal possible area 4(2n−1)2.
Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track
puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.
Source: MathNet,
licensed CC-BY-4.0.
Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic and difficulty added by this site.