Let R denote the set of all real numbers. Determine all injective functions f:R→R such that (f(a)−f(b))(f(b)−f(c))(f(c)−f(a))=f(ab2+bc2+ca2)−f(a2b+b2c+c2a) holds for all real numbers a,b,c.
Solution
f(x)=αx+β or f(x)=αx3+β where α∈{−1,0,1} and β∈R.
It is straightforward to check that above functions satisfy the equation. Now let f(x) satisfy the equation, which we denote E(a,b,c). Then clearly f(x)+C also does; therefore, we may suppose without loss of generality that f(0)=0.
By E(a,b,0) we get f(a)f(b)(f(a)−f(b))=f(a2b)−f(ab2).(1) Let κ:=f(1) and note that κ=f(1)=f(0)=0 by injectivity. Putting b=1 in (1) we get κf(a)(f(a)−κ)=f(a2)−f(a).(2) Subtracting the same equality for −a we get κ(f(a)−f(−a))(f(a)+f(−a)−κ)=f(−a)−f(a). Now, if a=0, by injectivity we get f(a)−f(−a)=0 and thus f(a)+f(−a)=κ−κ−1=:λ(3) It follows that f(a)−f(b)=f(−b)−f(−a) for all non-zero a,b. Replace non-zero numbers a,b in (1) with −a,−b, respectively, and add the two equalities. Due to (3) we get (f(a)−f(b))(f(a)f(b)−f(−a)f(−b))=0, thus f(a)f(b)=f(−a)f(−b)=(λ−f(a))(λ−f(b)) for all non-zero a=b. If λ=0, this implies f(a)+f(b)=λ that contradicts injectivity when we vary b with fixed a. Therefore, λ=0 and κ=±1. Thus f is odd. Replacing f with −f if necessary (this preserves the original equation) we may suppose that f(1)=1.
Now, (2) yields f(a2)=f2(a). Summing relations (1) for pairs (a,b) and (a,−b), we get −2f(a)f2(b)=−2f(ab2), i.e. f(a)f(b2)=f(ab2). Putting b=x for each non-negative x we get f(ax)=f(a)f(x) for all real a and non-negative x. Since f is odd, this multiplicity relation is true for all a,x. Also, from f(a2)=f2(a) we see that f(x)≥0 for x≥0. Next, f(x)>0 for x>0 by injectivity.
Assume that f(x) for x>0 does not have the form f(x)=xτ for a constant τ. The known property of multiplicative functions yields that the graph of f is dense on (0,∞)2. In particular, we may find positive b<1/10 for which f(b)>1. Also, such b can be found if f(x)=xτ for some τ<0. Then for all x we have x2+xb2+b≥0 and so E(1,b,x) implies that f(b2+bx2+x)=f(x2+xb2+b)+(f(b)−1)(f(x)−f(b)(f(x)−1))≥−((f(b)−1)3)/4 is bounded from below since (t−f(1))(t−f(b))≥−4(f(b)−f(1))2 for t=f(x) is used. Hence, f is bounded from below on (b2−4b1,+∞), and since f is odd it is bounded from above on (0,4b1−b2). This is absurd if f(x)=xτ for τ<0, and contradicts to the above dense graph condition otherwise.
Therefore, f(x)=xτ for x>0 and some constant τ>0. Dividing E(a,b,c) by (a−b)(b−c)(c−a)=(ab2+bc2+ca2)−(a2b+b2c+c2a) and taking a limit when a,b,c all go to 1 (the decided ratios tend to the corresponding derivatives, say, a−baτ−bτ→(xτ)x=1′=τ), we get τ3=τ⋅3τ−1, τ2=3τ−1, F(τ):=3τ/2−1/2−τ=0. Since function F is strictly convex, it has at most two roots, and we get τ∈{1,3}. □
Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track
puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.
Source: MathNet,
licensed CC-BY-4.0.
Statement translated into English from zh; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.