a. Examine if there is a real number x, such that both x+3 and x2+3 are rational numbers.
b. Examine if there is a real number y, such that both y+3 and y3+3 are rational numbers.
Solution
a. Let x+3=q, x2+3=p with p,q∈Q. Then x=q−3⇒x2=q2−2q3+3 so substituting in the second one gives: (q2−2q3+3)+3=p⇔−3(2q−1)=p−q2−3 It follows that 2q−1=0⇔q=21. In this case, p=q2+3⇒p=41+3=413 and x=21−3.
b. Let y+3=q, y3+3=p with p,q∈Q. Then y=q−3⇒y3=q3−3q23+9q−33 so substituting in the second one gives: (q3−3q23+9q−33)+3=p⇔−3(3q2+2)=p−q3−9q⇔3=3q2+2q3+9q−p∈Q which is absurd.
Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track
puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.
Source: MathNet,
licensed CC-BY-4.0.
Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic and difficulty added by this site.