CombinatoricsDifficulty 5.8AIME, harderProve itUnited States
Problem:
There is a unit circle that starts out painted white. Every second, you choose uniformly at random an arc of arclength 1 of the circle and paint it a new color. You use a new color each time, and new paint covers up old paint. Let cn be the expected number of colors visible after n seconds. Compute limn→∞cn.
Solutions — 4
Solution 1
Solution:
A more rigorous way to see this is the two radii created on the most recent turn have a probability 1 of being exposed; the two radii created last turn each have a probability 1−p of being exposed; the two radii created two turns ago each have a probability (1−p)2 of being exposed, and so on. Thus, on turn n, the expected number of exposed radii is 2(1+(1−p)+(1−p)2+⋯+(1−p)n−1) This geometric series converges to p2 as n grows.
Solution 2
Solution:
Notice that colors always appear in contiguous arcs on the circle (i.e. there's never a color that appears in two disconnected arcs). So the number of distinct visible colors is equal to the number of radii that serve as boundaries between colors. Each time we place a new color, we create 2 more of these radii. However, if the expected number of colors after turn n is constant, we must expect to remove 2 of these radii each turn. This is only possible when there are 4π total radii, since we expect to remove 2π1 of them each time.
Solution 3
Solution:
Consider the probability that the k-th last added arc is visible. Suppose there are j arcs after the k-th last arc that partially covers this arc. Then the probability that the k-th last arc is still visible is 2jj+1, since this is equivalent to randomly choosing j positions within the k-th last arc to place an arc in, then randomly choosing a direction, and there are 2j ways to choose directions and j+1 of them are good. The probability that any arc partially covers the k-th last arc is 2π2. Putting everything together, the probability that the k-th last arc is visible is j=0∑k−12jj+1⋅(jk−1)⋅(2π2)j⋅(1−2π2)k−1−j so the answer is 1+k=2∑nj=0∑k−12jj+1⋅(jk−1)⋅(2π2)j⋅(1−2π2)k−1−j (as the last arc is definitely visible). We can write this as 1+k=2∑nj=0∑k−1(j+1)⋅(jk−1)⋅(2π1)j⋅(1−2π2)k−1−j Now, j=0∑k−11⋅(jk−1)⋅(2π1)j⋅(1−2π2)k−1−j=(2π1+1−2π2)k−1 by binomial theorem. We can write j⋅(jk−1)=(k−1)(j−1k−2), so j=0∑k−1j⋅(jk−1)⋅(2π1)j⋅(1−2π2)k−1−j=(k−1)j=1∑k−1(j−1k−2)⋅(2π1)j⋅(1−2π2)k−1−j=(k−1)j=0∑k−2(jk−2)⋅(2π1)j+1⋅(1−2π2)k−2−j=2πk−1⋅(2π1+1−2π2)k−2 Therefore the answer is 1+k=2∑n(1−2π1+2πk−1)(1−2π1)k−2 which is an arithmetic sequence times a geometric sequence. Standard techniques simplify this to 4π.
Solution 4
Solution:
We solve for the lifespan of an arc. Let f(x) represent the expected number of turns an arc of length 2πx will remain visible. Our final answer will be to calculate f(2π1). Then we get the recurrence f(x)=1+(2π2π−1−x)f(x)+2∫0xf(x)dx The 1 term comes from counting the fact that the arc is visible during the current turn. The (2π2π−1−x)f(x) term comes from the fact that there is a 2π2π−1−x chance that the next arc will not intersect the current arc, in which case the current arc would get an extra f(x) turns to live. The integral comes from the fact that we want to take the average of f(y) for y∼r[0,x], which corresponds to the next arc covering up 2π(x−y) of the current one. If we differentiate both sides, we end up with a differential equation. Solve it via separation. We end up with f(x)=4π2x+2π. Plugging in x=2π1 gets us 4π. In general, the answer is f(x)=k2x+k1, where we are placing arcs of length 2πk.
Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track
puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.
Source: MathNet,
licensed CC-BY-4.0.
Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.