AlgebraDifficulty 7.6National Olympiad, round 2Prove itMiddle European Mathematical Olympiad (MEMO)
Problem: Find all positive integers n for which there exist positive integers x1,x2,…,xn such that x121+x222+x324+⋯+xn22n−1=1
Solution
Solution: - n=1 : Here, x1:=1 provides a solution, since 121=1
- n=2 : Here, no solution exists. Indeed, x1=1 or x2=1 yields x121+x222>1, while x1,x2≥2 leads to x121+x222≤41+42=43<1
- n=4 : Here, (x1,x2,x3,x4):=(3,3,3,6) provides a solution, since 321+322+324+628=97+368=97+92=1
- Induction step from n to (n+2) : Let (y1,y2,…,yn) be a solution for n, i.e., y121+y222+y324+⋯+yn22n−1=1 Then (x1,x2,…,xn+2):=(2,2,4y1,4y2,…,4yn) is a solution for (n+2), since x121+x222+x324+⋯+xn+222n+1=221+222+(4y1)24+⋯+(4yn)22n+1=41+42+164[(y1)21+⋯+(yn)22n−1]=43+41⋅1=1 Using this induction step and the solutions for n=1 and n=4, we can construct solutions for all n≥3.
Solution 1a. There are other induction steps possible. For example from n to (n+3) : Let (y1,y2,…,yn) be a solution for n, i.e., y121+y222+y324+⋯+yn22n−1=1 Then (x1,x2,…,xn+3):=(3,3,3,6y1,6y2,…,6yn) is a solution for (n+3), since x121+x222+x324+⋯+xn+322n+2=321+322+324+(6y1)28+⋯+(6yn)22n+2=91+92+94+368[(y1)21+⋯+(yn)22n−1]=97+92⋅1=1
Solution 2. As in the previous solution, we can show that there does not exist a solution for n=2 and find explicit solutions for n=1 and n=3. We construct further solutions by induction. Let (y1,y2,…,yn) be a solution for n≥3. Then setting xn−2=xn+1:=3yn−2 and xi:=yi for all other i is a solution for n+1, since for the sum of the terms corresponding to xn−2 and xn+1 (which are the only ones that differ between the solutions for n and n+1 ) we get xn−222n−3+xn+122n=9yn−222n−3+9yn−222n=9yn−22(1+8)⋅2n−3=yn−222n−3 thereby keeping the sum of all terms equal.
Solution 3. As in the other solutions, we can show that there does not exist a solution for n=2. Also, we can find explicit solutions for n=4,n=6 and n=8. Now we prove that we can find suitable integers for all other n : For n=2k+1 (where k is a suitable non-negative integer), we can choose x1=⋯=xn−1=2k,xn=22k to obtain i=1∑nxi22i−1=i=1∑2k22k2i−1+24k22k=22k2−122k−1+22k1=1 For n=2k with an integer k≥5, observe that, by setting xi=22i−1 for odd i and xi=22i−1 for even i, we have i=1∑2kxi22i−1=j=1∑k(22j−222j−2+22j−222j−1)=j=1∑k(1+2)=3k If we can modify the xi in order to obtain some square number m2 on the right hand side, we can in a second step multiply each xi by m to obtain a sum of 1 . Observe that all xi for i>2 are even. We show that there is a square divisible by 3 that can be obtained by replacing some of the xi (with i>2 ) by xi′:=xi/2 : Note that for odd i, this increases the sum by 4−1=3 and for even i, this increases the sum by 8−2=6. Since there are k−1 odd and k−1 even indexes to choose from, we can increase the sum by every number l that is divisible by three and satisfies 0≤l≤3(k−1)+6(k−1)=9k−9. Because of k≥5 and therefore 3k<k, the smallest square m2≥3k which is divisible by 3 certainly satisfies (3k)2=3k≤m2≤(3k+3)2=3k+63k+9<9k+9 In particular, m2≤9k+6 because m is divisible by 3 . This means that in order to increase 3k to m2, we have to add a number between 0 and 6k+6 to the sum above. However, 6k+6≤9k−9 because k≥5 and by the above argument, we can always do that. To summarize, we first set the xi as above, then select up to 2k−2 of them to be divided by 2 , then multiply all of them by m, yielding a right hand side of 1 .
Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track
puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.
Source: MathNet,
licensed CC-BY-4.0.
Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.