Problem:
Given are natural numbers such that for all , it holds that
Prove that some of the numbers is equal to 1. (Dušan Đukić)
Problem:
Given are natural numbers such that for all , it holds that
Prove that some of the numbers is equal to 1. (Dušan Đukić)
Solution:
The key fact is that, if and are perfect squares and , then is not a square. Indeed, then .
Let be all the primes less than 2016. For consider the binary sequence , where if the exponent of in the product is even, and otherwise. Since there are only possibilities for the sequence , for every among the sequences there exist two that are equal, say and (), and then is a perfect square not greater than .
Suppose that in the sequence there are no ones. Take ; certainly . We have seen that there exist indices , such that is a perfect square. However, since , by the fact from the beginning, and cannot simultaneously be squares, which is a contradiction.