Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /39 of 49

, 2022

Combinatorics Difficulty 6.7 National Olympiad Prove it Bulgaria

In each of the cells of an n×mn \times m table is written one of the letters aa, bb, or cc. The corresponding letter in every two rows, respectively every two columns of the table, coincide in at most k0k \ge 0 positions. Determine mm, nn and kk, if
2mn+6k3(m+n)k+1. \frac{2mn + 6k}{3(m + n)} \ge k + 1.

Solution

Denote the table rows by u1,u2,,unu_1, u_2, \dots, u_n. Let d(ui,uj)d(u_i, u_j), iji \ne j be the number of positions, in which the rows uiu_i and uju_j differ. According to the statement d(ui,uj)mkd(u_i, u_j) \ge m - k. Then:
(1)S=1i<jnd(ui,uj)n(n1)2(mk). (1) \qquad S = \sum_{1 \le i < j \le n} d(u_i, u_j) \ge \frac{n(n-1)}{2}(m-k).

Consider an arbitrary table column and let it contain xx letters aa, yy letters bb, and zz letters cc, with x+y+z=nx+y+z=n. The contribution to SS of this column is exactly xy+xz+yzxy+xz+yz, and due to the inequality
n2=(x+y+z)23(xy+xz+yz) n^2 = (x + y + z)^2 \ge 3(xy + xz + yz)
it follows that every column adds at most n23\frac{n^2}{3} to the value of SS (this is the case iff 33 divides nn and every column there are exactly n3\frac{n}{3} letters of each type). Now (1) gives rise to:
(2)mn23Sn(n1)2(mk)    mn+3k3kn+3m. (2) \qquad \frac{mn^2}{3} \ge S \ge \frac{n(n-1)}{2}(m-k) \iff mn + 3k \le 3kn + 3m.

Repeating the arguments, when replacing rows and columns leads to:
(3)mn+3k3km+3n. (3) \qquad mn + 3k \le 3km + 3n.
We add (2) and (3) to obtain 2mn+6k3(m+n)(k+1)2mn+6k3(m+n)k+12mn+6k \le 3(m+n)(k+1) \Leftrightarrow \frac{2mn+6k}{3(m+n)} \le k+1. Therefore, 2mn+6k3(m+n)=k+1\frac{2mn+6k}{3(m+n)} = k+1, mn+3k=3kn+3mmn+3k = 3kn+3m, and mn+3k=3km+3nmn+3k = 3km+3n (meaning also that both mm and nn are divisible by 33). From 3kn+3m=3km+3n(k1)(nm)=03kn+3m = 3km+3n \Leftrightarrow (k-1)(n-m) = 0, it follows that either k=1k=1 or m=nm=n. For k=1k=1, mn+3=3m+3nmn+3 = 3m+3n, which is impossible, since 33 divides mm and nn, thus 99 divides the RHS but not the LHS. For m=nm=n, m23(k+1)m+3k=0m^2-3(k+1)m+3k=0, with discriminant D=9k2+18k+912k=(3k+1)2+8D = 9k^2+18k+9-12k = (3k+1)^2+8 a perfect square. From (3k+1)2+8=t2(3k+1)^2+8 = t^2 we deduce that the difference between two perfect squares is 88, which holds

true only for t=3t=3 and k=0k=0. In conclusion m=n=3m=n=3 and the table is:

abc
bca
cab

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.