Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /14 of 25

Number theory Difficulty 7.8 National Olympiad, round 2 Prove it European Girls' Mathematical Olympiad (EGMO)

Problem:

Let nn be a positive integer.

a. Prove that there exists a set SS of 6n6 n pairwise different positive integers, such that the least common multiple of any two elements of SS is no larger than 32n232 n^{2}.

b. Prove that every set TT of 6n6 n pairwise different positive integers contains two elements the least common multiple of which is larger than 9n29 n^{2}.

Solution

Solution:

a.
Let the set AA consist of the 4n4 n integers 1,2,,4n1, 2, \ldots, 4 n and let the set BB consist of the 2n2 n even integers 4n+2,4n+4,,8n4 n + 2, 4 n + 4, \ldots, 8 n. We claim that the 6n6 n-element set S=ABS = A \cup B has the desired property.

Indeed, the least common multiple of two (even) elements of BB is no larger than 8n(8n/2)=32n28 n \cdot (8 n / 2) = 32 n^{2}, and the least common multiple of some element of AA and some element of ABA \cup B is at most their product, which is at most 4n8n=32n24 n \cdot 8 n = 32 n^{2}.

b.
We prove the following lemma: "If a set UU contains m+1m + 1 integers, where m2m \geqslant 2, that are all not less than mm, then some two of its elements have least common multiple strictly larger than m2m^{2}."

Let the elements of UU be u1>u2>>um+1mu_{1} > u_{2} > \cdots > u_{m+1} \geqslant m. Note that 1/u11/ui1/m1 / u_{1} \leqslant 1 / u_{i} \leqslant 1 / m for 1im+11 \leqslant i \leqslant m+1. We partition the interval [1/u1;1/m][1 / u_{1} ; 1 / m] into mm subintervals of equal length. By the pigeonhole principle, there exist indices i,ji, j with 1i<jm+11 \leqslant i < j \leqslant m+1 such that 1/ui1 / u_{i} and 1/uj1 / u_{j} belong to the same subinterval. Hence
0<1uj1ui1m(1m1u1)<1m2. 0 < \frac{1}{u_{j}} - \frac{1}{u_{i}} \leqslant \frac{1}{m} \left( \frac{1}{m} - \frac{1}{u_{1}} \right) < \frac{1}{m^{2}}.
Now 1/uj1/ui1 / u_{j} - 1 / u_{i} is a positive fraction with denominator lcm(ui,uj)\operatorname{lcm}(u_{i}, u_{j}). The above thus yields the lower bound lcm(ui,uj)>m2\operatorname{lcm}(u_{i}, u_{j}) > m^{2}, completing the proof of the lemma.

Applying the lemma with m=3nm = 3 n to the 3n+13 n + 1 largest elements of TT, which are all not less than 3n3 n, we arrive at the desired statement.

A Variant.

Alternatively, for part (b), we prove the following lemma: "If a set UU contains m2m \geqslant 2 integers that all are greater than mm, then some two of its elements have least common multiple strictly larger than m2m^{2}."

Let u1>u2>>umu_{1} > u_{2} > \cdots > u_{m} be the elements of UU. Since um>m=m2/mu_{m} > m = m^{2} / m, there exists a smallest index kk such that uk>m2/ku_{k} > m^{2} / k. If k=1k = 1, then u1>m2u_{1} > m^{2}, and the least common multiple of u1u_{1} and u2u_{2} is strictly larger than m2m^{2}. So let us suppose k>1k > 1 from now on, so that we have uk>m2/ku_{k} > m^{2} / k and uk1m2/(k1)u_{k-1} \leqslant m^{2} / (k-1). The greatest common divisor dd of uk1u_{k-1} and uku_{k} satisfies
duk1uk<m2k1m2k=m2(k1)k d \leqslant u_{k-1} - u_{k} < \frac{m^{2}}{k-1} - \frac{m^{2}}{k} = \frac{m^{2}}{(k-1)k}
This implies m2/(dk)>k1m^{2} / (d k) > k-1 and uk/d>k1u_{k} / d > k-1, and hence uk/dku_{k} / d \geqslant k. But then the least common multiple of uk1u_{k-1} and uku_{k} equals
uk1ukdukukd>m2kk=m2 \frac{u_{k-1} u_{k}}{d} \geqslant u_{k} \cdot \frac{u_{k}}{d} > \frac{m^{2}}{k} \cdot k = m^{2}
and the proof of the lemma is complete.

If we remove the 3n3 n smallest elements from set TT and apply the lemma with m=3nm = 3 n to the remaining elements, we arrive at the desired statement.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.