Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / Baltic Way Shortlist /35 of 92

Baltic Way Shortlist

Number theory Difficulty 8.2 Shortlist Prove it Baltic Way

An infinite set BB consisting of non-negative integers has the following property. For each a,b∈Ba, b \in B (a>ba > b) the number a−b(a,b)∈B\frac{a-b}{(a,b)} \in B. Prove that BB contains all non-negative integers. Here (a,b)(a, b) is the greatest common divisor of numbers aa and bb.

Solution

If dd is the greatest common divisor of all the numbers in set BB, let A={b/d:b∈B}A = \{b/d : b \in B\}. Then for each a,b∈Aa, b \in A (a>ba > b) we have
a−bd(a,b)∈A.(∗) \frac{a-b}{d(a,b)} \in A. \quad (*)
Observe that the greatest common divisor of the set AA equals 11, therefore we can find a finite subset A1⊂AA_1 \subset A for which gcd⁡A1=1\gcd A_1 = 1. We may think that the sum of elements of A1A_1 is minimal possible. Choose numbers a,b∈A1a, b \in A_1 (a>ba > b) and replace aa in the set A1A_1 with a−bd(a,b)\frac{a-b}{d(a,b)}. The greatest common divisor of the obtained set equals 11. But the sum of numbers decreases by this operation, which contradicts the minimality of A1A_1.

Thus, A1={1}A_1 = \{1\}. Therefore all the numbers in the set AA have residue 11 modulo dd. Take an arbitrary a=kd+1∈Aa = kd + 1 \in A and b=1b = 1. Then k∈Ak \in A by (∗)(*) and hence k=ds+1k = ds + 1. But (k,kd+1)=1(k, kd + 1) = 1, therefore kd+1−ds−1d=k−s=(d−1)s+1∈A\frac{kd+1-ds-1}{d} = k - s = (d-1)s + 1 \in A, so ss is divisible by dd. But s∈As \in A, therefore s−1s-1 is also divisible by dd, hence d=1d = 1 (that means that B=AB = A). Thus we have checked that if a=kd+1=k+1∈Aa = kd + 1 = k + 1 \in A then a−1=k∈Aa-1 = k \in A. Then all non-negative integers belong to AA because it is infinite.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,604 problems in a working order, from Junior Challenge level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.