Find the smallest positive integer satisfying the following condition, or prove that no positive integer satisfying the following condition exists:
There exist infinitely many tuples consisting of distinct positive rational numbers, such that
are both integers.
, 2018
Solution
It's clear that the only solution when is . Now we show that:
(1) There are only finitely many such that and are both integers.
Write and in the standard form. Then, and is equivalent to the following two conditions
(i) .
Notice that this leads to since .
Symmetrically, we get . This leads to .
(ii) .
A same procedure as above give us .
Hence, we must have , so the problem becomes finding such that and . It's clear that the only solutions are .
(2) There are infinitely many such that and are all integers.
In particular, let us show that there are infinitely many such solutions satisfying . Note that in this case, we can rewrite
with . We want this to satisfy
or equivalently,
We further fix , then we only need to show that there exists infinitely many integers such that
To show that there are infinitely many solutions to Eq. (1), we use the Vieta jumping (a.k.a. root flipping): starting with . The following algorithm generates infinitely many solutions. Let , and view Eq. (1) as a quadratic equation in of a fixed as
Then there exists another root of Eq. (2) which satisfies and . Since by assumption,
Hence, from solution , we obtain another solution with . We can then do this jump again, but this time treat as the variable in the quadratic equation. Continue this process, and we get infinitely many solutions.