Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /4 of 6

Geometry Difficulty 6.7 National olympiad Prove it Estonia

For which natural numbers n3n \ge 3 is it possible to cut a regular nn-gon into smaller pieces with regular polygonal shape? (The pieces may have different number of sides.)

Solution

Answer: 3, 4, 6, 12.

A regular triangle can be partitioned into four regular triangles of equal size (Fig. 23), a regular quadrilateral can be partitioned into four regular quadrilaterals with equal size (Fig. 24) and a regular hexagon can be partitioned into six regular triangles of equal size (Fig. 25). By building alternately equilateral triangles and squares onto the sides of a regular 12-gon, just a regular hexagon remains (Fig. 26), whence also a regular 12-gon can be partitioned in the required way.

Show now that other regular polygons cannot be partitioned into smaller regular polygons. For that, consider an arbitrary polygon that is partitioned into regular polygons. As the size of an internal angle of a regular polygon is less than 180180^\circ and not less than 6060^\circ, at most two regular polygons can meet at each vertex.

If a vertex of the big nn-gon is filled by just one smaller polygon then this piece is an nn-gon itself. Beside it, there must be space for at least one regular polygon. No more than two regular polygons can be placed there since the sum of the internal angles of these polygons and the nn-gon itself would exceed 180180^\circ. Two new pieces can be placed only if all these three pieces are triangular, which gives n=3n=3. It remains to study the case where there is exactly one polygon beside the nn-gonal piece. The size of the internal angle of the nn-gon being at most 120120^\circ implies n6n \le 6. The case n=5n=5 is impossible as its external angles are of size 7272^\circ but no regular polygon has internal angles of size strictly between 6060^\circ and 9090^\circ.

If each vertex of the big nn-gon is the meetpoint of two smaller regular polygons then one of them must be a triangle since other regular polygons have internal angles of size 9090^\circ or more. Beside a triangle, there is space for a triangle, a quadrilateral or a pentagon.

Figure 1
Figure 23
Figure 2
Figure 24
Figure 3
Figure 25
Figure 4
Figure 26

Figure 5
Figure 27

In the first two cases, the size of the internal angles of the nn-gon will be 120120^\circ and 150150^\circ, respectively, covering the cases n=6n = 6 and n=12n = 12. It remains to show that the third case with a triangle and a pentagon meeting at each vertex is impossible. Indeed, the side length of the pentagon must coincide with the side length of the initial big nn-gon, because it is impossible to place a regular polygon beside the pentagon along one side. For the same reason, another pentagon must be built to the second next side along the boundary of the initial polygon. These two pentagons meet at the third vertex of the triangle built to the side between (Fig. 27). But the ulterior angle between the sides of the pentagons at the meeting point has size 360210860=84360^\circ - 2 \cdot 108^\circ - 60^\circ = 84^\circ, which cannot be filled with interior angles of regular polygons.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic and difficulty added by this site.