Problem:
Let be a natural number and . For subsets and of we define to be the set of all those elements of which belong to exactly one of and . Let be a collection of subsets of such that for any two distinct elements and in the set has at least two elements. Show that has at most elements. Find all such collections with elements.
Solution
Solution:
For each subset of , we pair it with . Note that for any such pair not both and can be in . Since there are such pairs it follows that can have at most elements.
We shall show by induction on that if then contains either all the subsets with odd number of elements or all the subsets with even number of elements. The result is easy to see for . Suppose that the result is true for . We now consider the case . Let be the set of those elements in which contain and be the set of those elements which do not contain . By induction, can have at most elements. Further, for each element of we consider . This new collection also satisfies the required property, so it follows that has at most elements. Thus, if then it follows that . Further, by induction hypothesis, contains all those subsets of with (say) even number of elements. It then follows that contains all those subsets of which contain the element and which contain an even number of elements. This proves that contains either all the subsets with odd number of elements or all the subsets with even number of elements.