Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /21 of 36

, 2023

Algebra Difficulty 8.6 Shortlist Prove it Baltic Way

Find all (not necessarily strictly) monotonic functions f:RRf: \mathbb{R} \to \mathbb{R} with
f(x+y)3=f(x3)+f(y3) for all x,yR. f(x+y)^3 = f(x^3) + f(y^3) \text{ for all } x, y \in \mathbb{R}.

Solution

By substituting x=y=0x = y = 0 we see that f(0)3=2f(0)f(0)^3 = 2f(0) which implies f(0)32f(0)=0f(0)^3 - 2f(0) = 0. This means that f(0)=0f(0) = 0, f(0)=2f(0) = -\sqrt{2} or f(0)=2f(0) = \sqrt{2}.

By substituting y=0y = 0 we get f(x)3=f(x3)+f(03)=f(x3)+f(0)f(x)^3 = f(x^3) + f(0^3) = f(x^3) + f(0).

1) Let's first investigate the case f(0)=0f(0) = 0: in this case, f(x)3=f(x3)f(x)^3 = f(x^3), so (f(x+y))3=f(x3)+f(y3)=f(x)3+f(y)3(f(x+y))^3 = f(x^3) + f(y^3) = f(x)^3 + f(y)^3, in which case g(x)=f(x)3g(x) = f(x)^3 is a Cauchy functional equation and due to function being monotonic must be of the form cxc'x for some cRc' \in \mathbb{R}. This means that the solution must be f(x)=cx3=cx3f(x) = \sqrt[3]{c'x} = c\sqrt[3]{x}. Here x3\sqrt[3]{x} is a function defined on the entire set of real numbers R\mathbb{R}. Substituting this to the original equation we get (cx+y3)3=cx33+cy33(c\sqrt[3]{x+y})^3 = c\sqrt[3]{x^3} + c\sqrt[3]{y^3} which implies c3(x+y)=c(x+y)c^3(x+y) = c(x+y), so c3c=0c^3 - c = 0 and cc must be 1-1, 00 or 11. From this we get solutions f(x)=0f(x) = 0, f(x)=x3f(x) = \sqrt[3]{x} and f(x)=x3f(x) = -\sqrt[3]{x}.

2) Let's then investigate the case f(0)=2f(0) = \sqrt{2}: By substituting x=1x = 1 and y=0y = 0 we get f(1)3=f(13)+f(0)=f(1)+2f(1)^3 = f(1^3) + f(0) = f(1) + \sqrt{2} and f(1)3f(1)2=0f(1)^3 - f(1) - \sqrt{2} = 0. f(1)=2f(1) = \sqrt{2} is a solution, so this can be modified to (f(1)2)(f(1)2+2f(1)+1)=0(f(1) - \sqrt{2})(f(1)^2 + \sqrt{2}f(1) + 1) = 0. The latter part doesn't have real roots, so the only option is f(1)=2f(1) = \sqrt{2}. Now, substituting y=1y = 1 in the original equation we get f(x+1)3=f(x3)+2f(x+1)^3 = f(x^3) + \sqrt{2}. For x=1x = 1 we get f(2)3=f(1)+2=22f(2)^3 = f(1) + \sqrt{2} = 2\sqrt{2}. This means that also f(2)=2f(2) = \sqrt{2}.

Substituting x=2x = 2 and y=0y = 0 we get f(2)3=f(8)+f(0)f(2)^3 = f(8) + f(0) and substituting x=2,y=1x = 2, y = 1 we get f(3)3=f(8)+f(1)f(3)^3 = f(8) + f(1), from which we get f(3)=f(8)+f(1)3=f(8)+23=222+23=2f(3) = \sqrt[3]{f(8) + f(1)} = \sqrt[3]{f(8) + \sqrt{2}} = \sqrt[3]{2\sqrt{2} - \sqrt{2} + \sqrt{2}} = \sqrt{2}. Let us now use induction and assume that f(x)=2f(x) = \sqrt{2} for all x=1,2,,n1x = 1, 2, \dots, n-1. Now let's substitute x=n3,y=1x = \sqrt[3]{n}, y = 1: then f(n3+1)3=f(n33)+f(13)=f(n)+2f(\sqrt[3]{n} + 1)^3 = f(\sqrt[3]{n}^3) + f(1^3) = f(n) + \sqrt{2}, from which f(n)=f(n3+1)32=222=2f(n) = f(\sqrt[3]{n} + 1)^3 - \sqrt{2} = 2\sqrt{2} - \sqrt{2} = \sqrt{2}, since n3+1n1\sqrt[3]{n} + 1 \le n - 1 when n(n2)3n \le (n-2)^3, which is true when n4n \ge 4. Because ff is monotonic, also all real values between positive integer values must have f(x)=2f(x) = \sqrt{2}.

Let's then substitute x=1x = -1 and y=0y = 0 in the original equation: we get f(1)3=f(1)+f(0)=f(1)+2f(-1)^3 = f(-1)+f(0) = f(-1)+\sqrt{2}. From here we can use the same deductions as before to prove that f(x)=2f(x) = \sqrt{2} also for all negative xx.

3) Let's then investigate the case f(0)=2f(0) = -\sqrt{2}: By substituting x=1x = 1 and y=0y = 0 we get f(1)3=f(13)+f(0)=f(1)2f(1)^3 = f(1^3) + f(0) = f(1) - \sqrt{2} which implies f(1)3f(1)+2=0f(1)^3 - f(1) + \sqrt{2} = 0. f(1)=2f(1) = -\sqrt{2} is a solution, so this can be modified to (f(1)+2)(f(1)22f(1)+1)=0(f(1) + \sqrt{2})(f(1)^2 - \sqrt{2}f(1) + 1) = 0. The latter part doesn't have real roots, so the only option is f(1)=2f(1) = -\sqrt{2}. Now, substituting y=1y = 1 in the original equation we get f(x+1)3=f(x3)2f(x+1)^3 = f(x^3) - \sqrt{2}. For x=1x = 1 we get f(2)3=f(1)2=22f(2)^3 = f(1) - \sqrt{2} = -2\sqrt{2}. This means that also f(2)=2f(2) = -\sqrt{2}. Proving that f(3)=2f(3) = -\sqrt{2} goes similarly to 2). Similarly to case 2) we can also use induction to first prove that f(x)=2f(x) = -\sqrt{2} then use the similar deductions to 2) to prove it also for all negative xx.

It's easy to see that constant functions 00, 2\sqrt{2} and 2-\sqrt{2} fulfill the original functional equation. So in the end we get solutions f(x)=x3f(x) = \sqrt[3]{x}, f(x)=x3f(x) = -\sqrt[3]{x}, f(x)=0f(x) = 0, f(x)=2f(x) = \sqrt{2} and f(x)=2f(x) = -\sqrt{2}.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic and difficulty added by this site.