Find all (not necessarily strictly) monotonic functions f:R→R with f(x+y)3=f(x3)+f(y3) for all x,y∈R.
Solution
By substituting x=y=0 we see that f(0)3=2f(0) which implies f(0)3−2f(0)=0. This means that f(0)=0, f(0)=−2 or f(0)=2.
By substituting y=0 we get f(x)3=f(x3)+f(03)=f(x3)+f(0).
1) Let's first investigate the case f(0)=0: in this case, f(x)3=f(x3), so (f(x+y))3=f(x3)+f(y3)=f(x)3+f(y)3, in which case g(x)=f(x)3 is a Cauchy functional equation and due to function being monotonic must be of the form c′x for some c′∈R. This means that the solution must be f(x)=3c′x=c3x. Here 3x is a function defined on the entire set of real numbers R. Substituting this to the original equation we get (c3x+y)3=c3x3+c3y3 which implies c3(x+y)=c(x+y), so c3−c=0 and c must be −1, 0 or 1. From this we get solutions f(x)=0, f(x)=3x and f(x)=−3x.
2) Let's then investigate the case f(0)=2: By substituting x=1 and y=0 we get f(1)3=f(13)+f(0)=f(1)+2 and f(1)3−f(1)−2=0. f(1)=2 is a solution, so this can be modified to (f(1)−2)(f(1)2+2f(1)+1)=0. The latter part doesn't have real roots, so the only option is f(1)=2. Now, substituting y=1 in the original equation we get f(x+1)3=f(x3)+2. For x=1 we get f(2)3=f(1)+2=22. This means that also f(2)=2.
Substituting x=2 and y=0 we get f(2)3=f(8)+f(0) and substituting x=2,y=1 we get f(3)3=f(8)+f(1), from which we get f(3)=3f(8)+f(1)=3f(8)+2=322−2+2=2. Let us now use induction and assume that f(x)=2 for all x=1,2,…,n−1. Now let's substitute x=3n,y=1: then f(3n+1)3=f(3n3)+f(13)=f(n)+2, from which f(n)=f(3n+1)3−2=22−2=2, since 3n+1≤n−1 when n≤(n−2)3, which is true when n≥4. Because f is monotonic, also all real values between positive integer values must have f(x)=2.
Let's then substitute x=−1 and y=0 in the original equation: we get f(−1)3=f(−1)+f(0)=f(−1)+2. From here we can use the same deductions as before to prove that f(x)=2 also for all negative x.
3) Let's then investigate the case f(0)=−2: By substituting x=1 and y=0 we get f(1)3=f(13)+f(0)=f(1)−2 which implies f(1)3−f(1)+2=0. f(1)=−2 is a solution, so this can be modified to (f(1)+2)(f(1)2−2f(1)+1)=0. The latter part doesn't have real roots, so the only option is f(1)=−2. Now, substituting y=1 in the original equation we get f(x+1)3=f(x3)−2. For x=1 we get f(2)3=f(1)−2=−22. This means that also f(2)=−2. Proving that f(3)=−2 goes similarly to 2). Similarly to case 2) we can also use induction to first prove that f(x)=−2 then use the similar deductions to 2) to prove it also for all negative x.
It's easy to see that constant functions 0, 2 and −2 fulfill the original functional equation. So in the end we get solutions f(x)=3x, f(x)=−3x, f(x)=0, f(x)=2 and f(x)=−2.
Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track
puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.
Source: MathNet,
licensed CC-BY-4.0.
Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic and difficulty added by this site.