Let be an integer and . Prove that there do not exist rational numbers , not all of them equal to zero, such that
, 2014
Solution
Assume there exist rational numbers such that
Consider the polynomials
We then have . By Eisenstein's criterion, is irreducible
over the rationals, i.e. cannot be written as the product of two polynomials
of positive degree with rational coefficients.
Alternatively, this could be shown directly. Assume where and are monic polynomials with integer coefficients. Then and are integers and , hence one of these integers is equal to , say . This implies that the product of the absolute values of the complex roots of is equal to 1. Hence, there exists at least one complex number for which and . Then in contradiction to which implies . By Gauss' Lemma, is then irreducible over the rationals, too.
Hence, if , can only be 1 or . But the degree of is smaller
than the degree of , and so we conclude . This means that
there exist polynomials and such that .
This is in contradiction with , hence such rational numbers
cannot exist unless they are all equal to zero.