Given two positive integers and , find the smallest positive integer such that among any people, either there are of them who form pairs of mutually acquainted people or there are of them forming pairs of mutually unacquainted people.
Solution
Let the smallest positive integer satisfying the condition of the problem be denoted . We shall show that
Observe that, by symmetry, . Therefore it suffices to consider the case where , and to prove that
First we prove that
by an example. Call a group of people, every two of whom are mutually acquainted, a -clique. Consider a set of people consisting of a -clique together with an additional people none of whom know anyone else. (Call such people isolated.) Then there are not people forming mutually acquainted pairs, and there also are not people forming mutually unacquainted pairs. Thus by the definition of . [1 mark]
To establish (1), we need to prove that . To do this, we now show that
Let be a group of people. Notice that
If is a -clique, then contains people forming mutually acquainted pairs, and if has only isolated people, then contains people forming mutually unacquainted pairs. Otherwise, there are three people in , say and , such that are acquainted but are not. Now consider the group obtained by removing and from . has people, so by the definition of , either contains people forming mutually acquainted pairs, or else contains people forming mutually unacquainted pairs. In the former case, we add the acquainted pair to to form mutually acquainted pairs in . In the latter case, we add the unacquainted pair to to form mutually unacquainted pairs in . This proves (2). [3 marks]
Trivially, for all [1 mark], so holds whenever . Proceeding by induction on , by (2) we obtain
which completes the proof. [1 mark]