Problem:
Let be a positive integer and be the set of the first prime numbers. For every nonempty subset of denote by the product of the elements of . Let be a set of fractions of the form , where , , such that the product of any 7 elements of is an integer. What is the maximum possible cardinality of ?
Solution
Solution:
Consider the following three element sets
It is easy to check that the union of these sets satisfies the condition of the problem and has elements.
Suppose that there exists a set having elements that satisfies the condition of the problem. It is clear that every prime number appears in denominator at most 3 times.
Let be the largest possible set of prime numbers which appear exactly three times in denominator and no two prime numbers from appear in one and the same denominator. Then the following inequality holds true
i.e. .
Case 1. Let . Then is a union of sets of the type and it follows that does not appear in at most one of the numerators of the remaining fractions. In every there are at least two fractions whose numerators do not contain one ; otherwise there are two equal fractions. Therefore , a contradiction.
Case 2. Let . There are two cases:
a) The set is a union of sets of the form , where or and . If a denominator of a fraction not in is divisible by then we have as above that , i.e. , a contradiction. Otherwise the denominators of at most three fractions are divisible by . Therefore implying . It is easy to be seen that gives no solution.
b) Consider the set . Then observations analogous to those in a) imply , i.e. . For every it is easy to find an example of sets with elements.
Case 3. Let . To find a better one should have sets obtained by the primes from and two sets with two elements each obtained from and . As above we obtain , implying . Hence in this case we do not find a better .
When the answer is , and for the answer is .