Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / HMMT Invitational Competition /2 of 2

HMMT Invitational Competition

Number theory Difficulty 5.6 AIME, harder Prove it United States

Problem:
Let S={a1,…,an}S=\{a_{1}, \ldots, a_{n}\} be a finite set of positive integers of size n≥1n \geq 1, and let TT be the set of all positive integers that can be expressed as sums of perfect powers (including 11) of distinct numbers in SS, meaning
T={∑i=1naiei∣e1,e2,…,en≥0} T=\left\{\sum_{i=1}^{n} a_{i}^{e_{i}} \mid e_{1}, e_{2}, \ldots, e_{n} \geq 0\right\}
Show that there is a positive integer NN (only depending on nn) such that TT contains no arithmetic progression of length NN.

Solution

Solution:
In general we can assume that each ai>1a_{i}>1, since replacing ai=1a_{i}=1 by some large integer aa creates a set TT containing the original TT as a subset (by setting ei=0e_{i}=0).

We proceed by induction on nn. For the base case n=1n=1, an arithmetic progression of length at least 33 would give a1e1+a1e3=2a1e2a_{1}^{e_{1}}+a_{1}^{e_{3}}=2 a_{1}^{e_{2}} where e3>e2>e1e_{3}>e_{2}>e_{1}. But a1e3≥2a1e2a_{1}^{e_{3}} \geq 2 a_{1}^{e_{2}}, so this is impossible. Thus our result holds for n=1n=1.

Assume the result is true for some n−1n-1, and let An−1A_{n-1} be a number such that the longest progression when ∣S∣=n−1|S|=n-1 has length less than An−1A_{n-1}. Let MM be a large integer that we will choose later. Take an arithmetic progression of length 2M+12M+1, calling the terms b1,b2,…,b2M+1b_{1}, b_{2}, \ldots, b_{2M+1}. Note that b2M+1≤2bM+1b_{2M+1} \leq 2 b_{M+1}, since bb is a sequence of positive integers. For each term from bM+1b_{M+1} to b2M+1b_{2M+1} assign to it the maximum power that is part of the sum. Call this value c(bi)c(b_{i}). More explicitly, if bi=∑j=1najejb_{i}=\sum_{j=1}^{n} a_{j}^{e_{j}}, then c(bi)=max⁡(a1e1,a2e2,…,anen)c(b_{i})=\max \left(a_{1}^{e_{1}}, a_{2}^{e_{2}}, \ldots, a_{n}^{e_{n}}\right).

Since bM+1n≤c(bi)≤b2M+1≤2bM+1\frac{b_{M+1}}{n} \leq c(b_{i}) \leq b_{2M+1} \leq 2 b_{M+1} for M+1≤i≤2M+1M+1 \leq i \leq 2M+1, there are at most ∑j=1n(log⁡ai2n+1)≤n(log⁡22n+1)\sum_{j=1}^{n}\left(\log_{a_{i}} 2n+1\right) \leq n\left(\log_{2} 2n+1\right) different values of c(bi)c(b_{i}). By Van der Waerden's Theorem, there exists a value of MM such that coloring an arithmetic progression of length MM with n(log⁡22n+1)n\left(\log_{2} 2n+1\right) colors yields a monochromatic arithmetic progression of length An−1A_{n-1}. In particular, we can take M=W(An−1,n(log⁡22n+1))M=W\left(A_{n-1}, n\left(\log_{2} 2n+1\right)\right), where W(n,k)W(n, k) denotes the Van der Waerden number. So, we color bM+1,…,b2M+1b_{M+1}, \ldots, b_{2M+1} by their c(bi)c(b_{i}). Subtracting the common perfect power from each term of the monochromatic arithmetic progression obtained gives an arithmetic progression of An−1A_{n-1} integers expressible as the sum of perfect powers of distinct numbers in S∖ajS \setminus a_{j}. By the inductive hypothesis, this is a contradiction. So no arithmetic progression of length 2M+12M+1 can be contained in TT, and we can take An=2M+1A_{n}=2M+1.

By induction, we thus have such an AnA_{n} for all nn.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,604 problems in a working order, from Junior Challenge level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.