Problem:
Let be a finite set of positive integers of size , and let be the set of all positive integers that can be expressed as sums of perfect powers (including ) of distinct numbers in , meaning
Show that there is a positive integer (only depending on ) such that contains no arithmetic progression of length .
Solution
Solution:
In general we can assume that each , since replacing by some large integer creates a set containing the original as a subset (by setting ).
We proceed by induction on . For the base case , an arithmetic progression of length at least would give where . But , so this is impossible. Thus our result holds for .
Assume the result is true for some , and let be a number such that the longest progression when has length less than . Let be a large integer that we will choose later. Take an arithmetic progression of length , calling the terms . Note that , since is a sequence of positive integers. For each term from to assign to it the maximum power that is part of the sum. Call this value . More explicitly, if , then .
Since for , there are at most different values of . By Van der Waerden's Theorem, there exists a value of such that coloring an arithmetic progression of length with colors yields a monochromatic arithmetic progression of length . In particular, we can take , where denotes the Van der Waerden number. So, we color by their . Subtracting the common perfect power from each term of the monochromatic arithmetic progression obtained gives an arithmetic progression of integers expressible as the sum of perfect powers of distinct numbers in . By the inductive hypothesis, this is a contradiction. So no arithmetic progression of length can be contained in , and we can take .
By induction, we thus have such an for all .