Let be functions from the positive integers to the integers. Vlad the impala is jumping around the integer grid. His initial position is , and for every , his jump is
with eight possibilities in total. Is it always possible that Vlad can choose his jumps to return to his initial location infinitely many times when
(a) are polynomials with integer coefficients?
(b) are any pair of functions from the positive integers to the integers?
Solutions — 2
Solution 1
(a) Yes it is always possible. The key idea is the following: Let be the number of 1's in the binary expansion of .
Lemma: Given a polynomial with integer coefficients and degree at most , then
Proof of Lemma: The result is clear for . For , we have
So set , which is a polynomial of degree at most . Then
by induction, completing the proof of the lemma.
In particular, if we take
then whenever is a multiple of .
(b) No, it is not always possible. Let be any suitable function. Then, we construct inductively. There are at most possibilities for , so choose to be greater than the magnitude of all of them. Consequently cannot be .
Solution 2
(a) Given a polynomial of degree at most and integers , we claim that
for some choice of . (Which are allowed to depend on and .)
We proceed by induction on , the case being immediate. For the inductive step we define the polynomial which is a polynomial of degree at most . Then
for some choice of the 's giving
where and . This completes the proof of the claim.
Now the proof can be completed as in Solution 1.
(b) Apart from magnitude arguments, one could also use modulo arguments. For example, taking to be odd and to be even for every works.