Find the least real number with the following property: if the real numbers , , and are not all positive, then
Solutions — 3
Solution 1
The answer is .
We start with a lemma.
Lemma 1. If real numbers and are not all positive, then
Proof: Without loss of generality, we assume that .
We first assume that . Setting , reads
or
Expanding the left-hand side gives
or
which is evident as , , and .
We second assume that . Let . By our previous argument, we have
It is clear that , , and . Combining the last four inequalities gives , and this completes the proof of the lemma.
Now we show that if are not all positive real numbers, then
We consider three cases.
a. We assume that . Setting and then in the lemma gives the desired result.
b. We assume that . Setting and then in the lemma gives the desired result.
Finally, we confirm that the minimum value of is by noting that the equality holds in when .
Solution 2
We establish by showing
Note that is a quadratic in whose axis of symmetry (found by comparing the linear and quadratic terms) is at
For any , we have , so the absolute value of the second quantity on the right-hand side of the above equation is at most , which is less than . That is, the axis of symmetry occurs to the right side of the -axis, so we only decrease the difference between the sides by replacing by . But when , we only need to show
which is evident as .
Solution 3
This is the Calculus version of the second solution. We maintain the same notation as in the second solution. We have
or
It is evident that
as it is equivalent to . It follows that
that is, the first summand on the right-hand side of is not positive. It is also evident that
as it is equivalent to . If , then multiplying the inequalities
gives
If , then , and so
In either case, we have shown that the second summand in is also negative. We conclude that for . Hence reaches minimum when , and we can finish as we did in the second solution.