Number theoryDifficulty 8.7ShortlistProve itRomania
If k and n are positive integers, and k≤n, let M(n,k) denote the least common multiple of the numbers n,n−1,…,n−k+1. Let f(n) be the largest positive integer k≤n such that M(n,1)<M(n,2)<⋯<M(n,k). Prove that:
a) f(n)<3n, for all positive integers n;
b) if N is a positive integer, then f(n)>N for all but finitely many positive integers n.
Solution
a) Clearly, f(1)=1. Notice that M(n,k+1)=lcm(M(n,k),n−k),1≤k<n.(∗) Thus, M(n,k)≤M(n,k+1), and equality holds if and only if n−k divides M(n,k). If m>1, then M(m2,2)=m2(m2−1)=(m2−m)(m2+m), so M(m2,2) is divisible by m2−m, and hence so is M(m2,m). By (∗), M(m2,m)=M(m2,m+1), so f(m2)≤m for all positive integers m. With reference again to (∗), if M(n,k)=M(n,k+1), then M(n+ℓ,k+ℓ)=M(n+ℓ,k+ℓ+1), so f(n+ℓ)≤f(n)+ℓ for all positive integers ℓ and n. Finally, if m2≤n<(m+1)2, then n=m2+ℓ for some non-negative integer ℓ≤2m, so f(n)=f(m2+ℓ)≤f(m2)+ℓ≤m+ℓ≤3m≤3n, where one of the last two inequalities must in fact be a strict inequality.
b) We show that f(n)>N for all integers n>N!+N. Refer again to (∗) to write M(n,N+1)=lcm(M(n,N),n−N)=gcd(M(n,N),n−N)M(n,N)⋅(n−N)≥∏k=1Ngcd(n−k+1,n−N)M(n,N)⋅(n−N)≥∏k=1N(N−k+1)M(n,N)⋅(n−N)=N!M(n,N)⋅(n−N). Consequently, if n>N!+N, then M(n,1)<⋯<M(n,N)<M(n,N+1), so f(n)>N.
Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track
puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.
Source: MathNet,
licensed CC-BY-4.0.
Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.