Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /64 of 70

Number theory Difficulty 8.7 Shortlist Prove it Romania

If kk and nn are positive integers, and knk \le n, let M(n,k)M(n, k) denote the least common multiple of the numbers n,n1,,nk+1n, n-1, \dots, n-k+1. Let f(n)f(n) be the largest positive integer knk \le n such that M(n,1)<M(n,2)<<M(n,k)M(n, 1) < M(n, 2) < \dots < M(n, k). Prove that:

a) f(n)<3nf(n) < 3\sqrt{n}, for all positive integers nn;

b) if NN is a positive integer, then f(n)>Nf(n) > N for all but finitely many positive integers nn.

Solution

a) Clearly, f(1)=1f(1) = 1. Notice that
M(n,k+1)=lcm(M(n,k),nk),1k<n.() M(n, k + 1) = \operatorname{lcm}(M(n, k), n - k), \quad 1 \le k < n. \quad (*)
Thus, M(n,k)M(n,k+1)M(n, k) \le M(n, k+1), and equality holds if and only if nkn-k divides M(n,k)M(n, k). If m>1m > 1, then M(m2,2)=m2(m21)=(m2m)(m2+m)M(m^2, 2) = m^2(m^2 - 1) = (m^2 - m)(m^2 + m), so M(m2,2)M(m^2, 2) is divisible by m2mm^2 - m, and hence so is M(m2,m)M(m^2, m). By ()(*), M(m2,m)=M(m2,m+1)M(m^2, m) = M(m^2, m+1), so f(m2)mf(m^2) \le m for all positive integers mm. With reference again to ()(*), if M(n,k)=M(n,k+1)M(n, k) = M(n, k+1), then M(n+,k+)=M(n+,k++1)M(n + \ell, k + \ell) = M(n + \ell, k + \ell + 1), so f(n+)f(n)+f(n + \ell) \le f(n) + \ell for all positive integers \ell and nn. Finally, if m2n<(m+1)2m^2 \le n < (m+1)^2, then n=m2+n = m^2 + \ell for some non-negative integer 2m\ell \le 2m, so f(n)=f(m2+)f(m2)+m+3m3nf(n) = f(m^2 + \ell) \le f(m^2) + \ell \le m + \ell \le 3m \le 3\sqrt{n}, where one of the last two inequalities must in fact be a strict inequality.

b) We show that f(n)>Nf(n) > N for all integers n>N!+Nn > N! + N. Refer again to ()(*) to write
M(n,N+1)=lcm(M(n,N),nN)=M(n,N)(nN)gcd(M(n,N),nN)M(n,N)(nN)k=1Ngcd(nk+1,nN)M(n,N)(nN)k=1N(Nk+1)=M(n,N)(nN)N!. \begin{aligned} M(n, N + 1) &= \operatorname{lcm}(M(n, N), n - N) = \frac{M(n, N) \cdot (n - N)}{\operatorname{gcd}(M(n, N), n - N)} \\ &\ge \frac{M(n, N) \cdot (n - N)}{\prod_{k=1}^{N} \operatorname{gcd}(n - k + 1, n - N)} \ge \frac{M(n, N) \cdot (n - N)}{\prod_{k=1}^{N} (N - k + 1)} \\ &= \frac{M(n, N) \cdot (n - N)}{N!}. \end{aligned}
Consequently, if n>N!+Nn > N! + N, then M(n,1)<<M(n,N)<M(n,N+1)M(n, 1) < \dots < M(n, N) < M(n, N + 1), so f(n)>Nf(n) > N.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.