The sequence a1,a2,… is defined by the equalities a1=2, a2=12 and an+1=6an−an−1 for every positive integer n≥2. Prove that no member of this sequence is equal to a perfect power (greater than one) of a positive integer.
Solution
We shall use the following assertion.
Lemma. Let k≥2 be a positive integer. Then the equation 2x2k+1=y2 does not have solutions in positive integers.
Proof. Assume that x,y and k≥2 are positive integers such that 2x2k+1=y2 and x is minimum possible. It is obvious that x is even and y is odd. Let us denote x=2a and y=2b+1. Then 22k−1a2k=b(b+1) and (b,b+1)=1. There are two possibilities: - if b=x12k and b+1=22k−1x22k, x1,x2∈N, x1x2=a, then 22k−1x22k−x12k=1, which gives a contradiction modulo 4; - if b=22k−1x12k and b+1=x22k, x1,x2∈N, x1x2=a, then x22k−22k−1x12k=1, which leads to the equation y12=22k−1x12k+1, y1=x2k, where
we notice that x1<x. It is clear that the above argument of decreasing the degrees of 2 can be continued until we have degree at most 5. Therefore we reach the equation y02=8x02k+1, where x0<x and y0=y2k, y2∈N. Clearly, y0 is odd and we set y0=2c+1. We obtain c(c+1)=2x02k, where (c,c+1)=1. We have again two possibilities: - if c=x32k and c+1=2x42k, x3,x4∈N, x3x4=x0, then 4x42k=2c+2=y2k+1, whence (2x4k−1)(2x4k+1)=y2k. This leads to 2x4k−1=y3k, 2x4k+1=y4k, y3,y4∈N, y3y4=y2, and finally y4k−y3k=2, which is impossible; - if c=2x32k and c+1=x42k, x3,x4∈N, x3x4=x0, then 2x32k+1=(x4k)2, which contradicts to the choice of x as minimal. This completes the proof of the lemma.
The roots of the characteristic equation t2−6t+1=0 of our sequence are t1,2=3±22. Therefore we find (using the conditions a1=2 and a2=12) an=22(3+22)n−(3−22)n. Denote (3+22)n=αn+βn2, αn,βn∈N. Then (3−22)n=αn−βn2, αn=βn and αn2−2βn2=1. Now, if an is perfect power for some n, then the last two equalities give a contradiction with the lemma.
Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track
puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.
Source: MathNet,
licensed CC-BY-4.0.
Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic and difficulty added by this site.