Suppose a and b are real numbers such that the quadratic polynomial f(x)=x2+ax+b has no nonnegative real roots. Prove that there exist two polynomials g,h, whose coefficients are nonnegative real numbers, such that f(x)=h(x)g(x), for all real numbers x.
Solution
First Solution. Since f(x)=0 has no nonnegative real solutions, b=f(0)>0. If a≥0, then take g(x)=f(x),h(x)=1. Suppose that a<0. Since f(x)=0 has no nonnegative roots, we must have a2<4b. Replacing f(x) by b−1f(xb), we may assume that b=1.
Put c1=−a and f1(x)=f(x)=x2−c1x+1. Note that c12<4. Put f2(x)=f1(x)(x2+c1x+1)=x4−c2x2+1, where c2=c12−2. If c2≤0, take g(x)=f2(x),h(x)=g(x)/f(x) to satisfy the conclusion. If c2>0, then put f3(x)=f2(x)(x4+c2x2+1)=(x8−c3x4+1), so c3=c22−2. Proceeding in this way, suppose that fk(x)=(x2k−ckx2k−1+1), where ck=ck−12−2, and that ck≤0, then take g(x)=fk(x),h(x)=g(x)/f(x) to satisfy the conclusion.
If ck>0, then put fk+1(x)=fk(x)(x2k+ckx2k−1+1)=x2k+1−ck+1x2k+1.
Suppose that ct>0 for all positive integers t. Then, for a positive integer n, cn2>2, cn−12>2+2, cn−22>2+2+2, cn−32>2+2+2+2, ..., and in general cn−s2>2+2+2+2+⋯+2 (s terms 2 under the radical signs). By the AGM inequality, 2+2>222=21+21+41, and, in general, 2+2+2+2+⋯+2>21+21+41+⋯+2h+11, where there are h terms 2 under the radical sign. Hence c12>21+21+41+⋯+2m+11, for all positive integers m. Since the sum of the geometric progression 1+21+221+⋯+2n1+… is 2, while c12<4, this is a contradiction. Hence ct≤0 for some positive integer t, and the proof is complete.
Solution 2:
This is based on the following observation, viz., if p(x,θ)=x2−2cosθx+1, then p(x,θ)p(x,θ+π)=(x2−2cosθx+1)(x2+2cosθx+1)=x4−2(2cos2θ−1)x2+1=x4−2cos2θx2+1=p(x2,2θ).
To continue, as in the First Solution, it suffices to consider the case f(x)=x2−cx+1, where 0<c<2. Select θ∈(0,π/2), so that c=2cosθ. Then f(x)=p(x,θ) and so f(x)p(x,θ+π)=p(x2,2θ)=x4−2cos2θx2+1.
If cos2θ≤0, we stop and take g(x)=p(x2,2θ) and h(x)=p(x,θ+π). Otherwise, we repeat the process and use the fact that p(x2,2θ)p(x2,2θ+π)=p(x4,4θ).
We stop if cos4θ≤0, and put g(x)=p(x4,4θ),h(x)=p(x,θ+π)p(x2,2θ+π). Otherwise we continue. We stop at the nth stage where cos2nθ≤0, and cos2n−1θ>0, at which point we let g(x)=p(x2n,2nθ),h(x)=p(x,θ+π)k=1∏2n−1p(x2k,2kθ+π).
It's clear that g,h are polynomials whose coefficients are nonnegative, and that f=g/h.
Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track
puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.
Source: MathNet,
licensed CC-BY-4.0.
Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.