Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / IMO Shortlist /247 of 365

IMO Shortlist, 2016

Geometry Difficulty 8.8 Shortlist Prove it IMO

Let A1A_{1}, B1B_{1} and C1C_{1} be points on sides BCBC, CACA and ABAB of an acute triangle ABCABC respectively, such that AA1AA_{1}, BB1BB_{1} and CC1CC_{1} are the internal angle bisectors of triangle ABCABC. Let II be the incentre of triangle ABCABC, and HH be the orthocentre of triangle A1B1C1A_{1}B_{1}C_{1}. Show that
AH+BH+CH⩾AI+BI+CI. AH + BH + CH \geqslant AI + BI + CI.

Solution

Without loss of generality, assume α=∠BAC⩽β=∠CBA⩽γ=∠ACB\alpha = \angle BAC \leqslant \beta = \angle CBA \leqslant \gamma = \angle ACB. Denote by aa, bb, cc the lengths of BCBC, CACA, ABAB respectively. We first show that triangle A1B1C1A_{1}B_{1}C_{1} is acute.
Choose points DD and EE on side BCBC such that B1D∥ABB_{1}D \parallel AB and B1EB_{1}E is the internal angle bisector of ∠BB1C\angle BB_{1}C. As ∠B1DB=180∘−β\angle B_{1}DB = 180^{\circ} - \beta is obtuse, we have BB1>B1DBB_{1} > B_{1}D. Thus,
BEEC=BB1B1C>DB1B1C=BAAC=BA1A1C \frac{BE}{EC} = \frac{BB_{1}}{B_{1}C} > \frac{DB_{1}}{B_{1}C} = \frac{BA}{AC} = \frac{BA_{1}}{A_{1}C}
Therefore, BE>BA1BE > BA_{1} and 12∠BB1C=∠BB1E>∠BB1A1\frac{1}{2} \angle BB_{1}C = \angle BB_{1}E > \angle BB_{1}A_{1}. Similarly, 12∠BB1A>∠BB1C1\frac{1}{2} \angle BB_{1}A > \angle BB_{1}C_{1}. It follows that
∠A1B1C1=∠BB1A1+∠BB1C1<12(∠BB1C+∠BB1A)=90∘ \angle A_{1}B_{1}C_{1} = \angle BB_{1}A_{1} + \angle BB_{1}C_{1} < \frac{1}{2}(\angle BB_{1}C + \angle BB_{1}A) = 90^{\circ}
is acute. By symmetry, triangle A1B1C1A_{1}B_{1}C_{1} is acute.
Let BB1BB_{1} meet A1C1A_{1}C_{1} at FF. From α⩽γ\alpha \leqslant \gamma, we get a⩽ca \leqslant c, which implies
BA1=cab+c⩽aca+b=BC1 BA_{1} = \frac{ca}{b + c} \leqslant \frac{ac}{a + b} = BC_{1}
and hence ∠BC1A1⩽∠BA1C1\angle BC_{1}A_{1} \leqslant \angle BA_{1}C_{1}. As BFBF is the internal angle bisector of ∠A1BC1\angle A_{1}BC_{1}, this shows ∠B1FC1=∠BFA1⩽90∘\angle B_{1}FC_{1} = \angle BFA_{1} \leqslant 90^{\circ}. Hence, HH lies on the same side of BB1BB_{1} as C1C_{1}. This shows HH lies inside triangle BB1C1BB_{1}C_{1}. Similarly, from α⩽β\alpha \leqslant \beta and β⩽γ\beta \leqslant \gamma, we know that HH lies inside triangles CC1B1CC_{1}B_{1} and AA1C1AA_{1}C_{1}.
Figure 1
As α⩽β⩽γ\alpha \leqslant \beta \leqslant \gamma, we have α⩽60∘⩽γ\alpha \leqslant 60^{\circ} \leqslant \gamma. Then ∠BIC⩽120∘⩽∠AIB\angle BIC \leqslant 120^{\circ} \leqslant \angle AIB. Firstly, suppose ∠AIC⩾120∘\angle AIC \geqslant 120^{\circ}.
Rotate points BB, II, HH through 60∘60^{\circ} about AA to B′B', I′I', H′H' so that B′B' and CC lie on different sides of ABAB. Since triangle AI′IAI'I is equilateral, we have
AI+BI+CI=I′I+B′I′+IC=B′I′+I′I+IC \begin{equation*} AI + BI + CI = I'I + B'I' + IC = B'I' + I'I + IC \tag{1} \end{equation*}
Similarly,
AH+BH+CH=H′H+B′H′+HC=B′H′+H′H+HC \begin{equation*} AH + BH + CH = H'H + B'H' + HC = B'H' + H'H + HC \tag{2} \end{equation*}
As ∠AII′=∠AI′I=60∘\angle AII' = \angle AI'I = 60^{\circ}, ∠AI′B′=∠AIB⩾120∘\angle AI'B' = \angle AIB \geqslant 120^{\circ} and ∠AIC⩾120∘\angle AIC \geqslant 120^{\circ}, the quadrilateral B′I′ICB'I'I C is convex and lies on the same side of B′CB'C as AA.
Next, since HH lies inside triangle ACC1ACC_{1}, HH lies outside B′I′ICB'I'I C. Also, HH lying inside triangle ABIABI implies H′H' lies inside triangle AB′I′AB'I'. This shows H′H' lies outside B′I′ICB'I'I C and hence the convex quadrilateral B′I′ICB'I'I C is contained inside the quadrilateral B′H′HCB'H'H C. It follows that the perimeter of B′I′ICB'I'I C cannot exceed the perimeter of B′H′HCB'H'H C. From (1) and (2), we conclude that
AH+BH+CH⩾AI+BI+CI. AH + BH + CH \geqslant AI + BI + CI.
For the case ∠AIC<120∘\angle AIC < 120^{\circ}, we can rotate BB, II, HH through 60∘60^{\circ} about CC to B′B', I′I', H′H' so that B′B' and AA lie on different sides of BCBC. The proof is analogous to the previous case and we still get the desired inequality.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,604 problems in a working order, from Junior Challenge level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.