Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /245 of 397

, 2023

Combinatorics Difficulty 6.2 National Olympiad Prove it Taiwan

Integers nn and kk satisfy n>2023k3n > 2023k^3. Kingdom Kitty has nn cities, with at most one road between each pair of cities. It is known that the total number of roads in the kingdom is at least 2n3/22n^{3/2}. Prove that we can choose 3k+13k + 1 cities such that the total number of roads with both ends being a chosen city is at least 4k4k.

Solution

Let us first remove vertices of smallest degree from the graph one by one, until in the remaining graph G=(V,E)G' = (V', E') every vertex has degree greater than n1/2n^{1/2}. Note that the above operation removes at most n×n1/2n \times n^{1/2} edges, hence En3/2|E'| \ge n^{3/2}, and thus m=V2En3/4m = |V'| \ge \sqrt{2|E'|} \ge n^{3/4}.

Take arbitrarily a vertex vv in VV', and let V1V_1 and V2V_2 be respectively the sets of vertices in VV at distance 1 and 2 from vv. Color all edges from vv to V1V_1 blue. Moreover, for each vertex yy in V2V_2, choose a vertex xx in V1V_1 that is connected to yy, and color xyxy blue as well.

We claim that we can always find at least kk distinct 3-cycles or 4-cycles passing through vv. First, since V1=deg(v)>n1/2m1/2|V_1| = \deg(v) > n^{1/2} \ge m^{1/2}, this means that the number of edges from V1V_1 to V1V2V_1 \cap V_2 is at least m1/2m^{1/2}. But at the same time, note that the number of blue edges is V2VV1<mm1/2|V_2| \le |V| - |V_1| < m - m^{1/2}, hence this shows that among the edges from V1V_1 to V1V2V_1 \cap V_2, at least m1/2km^{1/2} \ge k of them are not blue, and each such edge, together with at most three blue edges, forms a 3-cycle passing through vv (if it goes from V1V_1 to V1V_1) or a 4-cycle (if it goes from V1V_1 to V2V_2).

Now, let CC be the union of these 3-cycles and 4-cycles. Note that CC has at most 3k+13k+1 vertices (noting that they all share the vertex vv), and the total number of edges exceeds the total number of vertices by k1k-1 (based on the structure of the cycles). This shows that, as long as the connected component containing the initially chosen vv has at least 3k+13k+1 vertices, we can start from CC and gradually add new vertices from the connected region, until the total number of vertices reaches 3k+13k+1, at which point the total number of edges is at least (3k+1)+(k1)=4k(3k+1) + (k-1) = 4k. Q.E.D.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement translated into English from zh; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.