Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / IMO TST Day 2

IMO TST Day 2

Geometry Difficulty 8.8 Shortlist Prove it India

In triangle ABCABC, let DD be the foot of the perpendicular from AA to line BCBC. Point KK lies inside triangle ABCABC such that ∠KAB=∠KCA\angle KAB = \angle KCA and ∠KAC=∠KBA\angle KAC = \angle KBA. The line through KK perpendicular to line DKDK meets the circle with diameter BCBC at points XX and YY. Prove that AX⋅DY=DX⋅AYAX \cdot DY = DX \cdot AY.

Solution

Assume AB≠ACAB \neq AC for all solutions as in the case that AB=ACAB = AC, X,YX, Y are symmetric about ADAD and the result is immediate.
Let MM be the midpoint of BCBC. Let ω=(BC)\omega = (BC) and Ω=(ABC)\Omega = (ABC).
We prove some preliminary results here which will be freely used across different proofs.
Let TT be the intersection of the BB and CC tangents to Ω\Omega.

Claim 0.1 (BKOCT) is cyclic.
Proof. Let TT be a point such that TT is the intersection of the tangents from BB and CC to (ABC)(ABC). Now, observe that from the given angle conditions, that ∠BKC=180∘−A=∠BOC\angle BKC = 180^\circ - A = \angle BOC where OO is the center of Ω\Omega. Also, ∠BTC=A\angle BTC = A, thus, (BKOCT)(BKOCT) is cyclic. □\square

Claim 0.2 The point KK lies on the AA symmedian in △ABC\triangle ABC.
Proof. From Claim 0.1 ∠TKC=A\angle TKC = A. Also, from the given angle conditions, we have that ∠AKC=180∘−A\angle AKC = 180^\circ - A. Thus, A,K,TA, K, T are collinear. This gives the desired result. □\square

Claim 0.3 ∠AKO=90∘\angle AKO = 90^\circ.
Proof. As ∠OKT=90∘\angle OKT = 90^\circ, we have ∠AKO=90∘\angle AKO = 90^\circ. □\square

Claim 0.4 Reflection of AA in KK lies on Ω\Omega.
Proof. Follows immediately from Claim 0.3. □\square

Let K′K' be the reflection of AA in KK, we have proved that K′∈ΩK' \in \Omega.

Claim 0.5 The reflection of K′K' in BCBC lies on the AA-median of △ABC\triangle ABC.
Proof. Let K′′K'' be the point on the AA median such that MA⋅MK′′=MB2MA \cdot MK'' = MB^2.
Thus, we get that
∠K′CB=∠K′AB=∠MAC=∠MCK′′=∠BCK′′ \angle K'CB = \angle K'AB = \angle MAC = \angle MCK'' = \angle BCK''
Similarly, ∠K′BC=∠CBK′′\angle K'BC = \angle CBK''. Thus, K′′K'' is the reflection of K′K' in BCBC as required. □\square

We call the point K′′K'', the AA-HM point in △ABC\triangle ABC.

Claim 0.6 If SS is the intersection of the AA tangent with BCBC, then ∠SKA=90∘\angle SKA = 90^\circ.
Proof. Since AKAK is the symmedian, the tangents from SS to Ω\Omega are at A,K′A, K'. Thus, S,K,OS, K, O are collinear as this is the perpendicular bisector of AK′AK'. Thus, we get the desired result. □\square

Let D′D' be the point such that (BC;DD′)=−1(BC; DD') = -1, or equivalently if E,FE, F are feet of perpendiculars from B,CB, C onto ABAB and ACAC respectively then D′=EF∩BCD' = EF \cap BC.

Claim 0.7 D′K′′⊥AMD'K'' \perp AM
Proof. Observe that
∠MDA=90∘, MD⋅MD′=MB2=MK′′⋅MA  ⟹  ∠MK′′D′=90∘ \angle MDA = 90^\circ, \ MD \cdot MD' = MB^2 = MK'' \cdot MA \implies \angle MK''D' = 90^\circ
□\square

Solution Path A
We wish to show that DD lies on the AA-Appolonian circle in △XAY\triangle XAY. Thus, it suffices to show that there exists point PP on line XYXY with PA2=PX⋅PY=PD2PA^2 = PX \cdot PY = PD^2 since such a point PP would be the center of the AA-Appolonian circle in △XAY\triangle XAY, and if PA2=PD2PA^2 = PD^2, then DD would be on the Appolonian circle as well.

Solution A1
We will show that the perpendicular bisector of ADAD, the line XYXY and the radical axis of point circle ⊙(A)\odot(A) and ⊙(BC)\odot(BC) concur. The point of concurrence is the required point PP. The latter radical axis is simply the midline of AA with its polar in ⊙(BC)\odot(BC).
Claim 1 A,K′′A, K'' are inverses in ω\omega.
Proof. Same as Claim 0.5 in Solution Preliminary
□\square
By homothety at AA of ratio +2+2, the conclusion is same as showing that line BCBC and the polar of AA in ⊙(BC)\odot(BC), and the line through K′K' perpendicular to A′K′A'K' concur. However, the polar is simply the line through K′′K'' perpendicular to AK′′AK''; the reflection of the other line in BCBC, and the concurrence is obvious.
□\square

Solution A2
We claim that PP is the midpoint of AD′AD'.
Claim 1 It is sufficient to prove that ∠PKD=90∘\angle PKD = 90^\circ.
Proof. Observe that MB⋅MC=MD⋅MD′MB \cdot MC = MD \cdot MD' and thus (ADD′)(ADD') and (BC)(BC) are orthogonal. Thus, if P,XP, X and YY are collinear, then powω(P)=PX⋅PY\text{pow}_\omega(P) = PX \cdot PY but since (ADD′)(ADD') and (BC)(BC) are orthogonal, we have that powω(P)=PA2\text{pow}_\omega(P) = PA^2. Thus, we get that PA2=PX⋅PY=PD2=PD′2PA^2 = PX \cdot PY = PD^2 = PD'^2, and we will be done.
Thus, we just want P,X,YP, X, Y collinear that is ∠PKD=90∘\angle PKD = 90^\circ.
□\square
□\square
Taking homothety +2+2 from AA, we get that if A′A' is the reflection of AA in BCBC and if K′K' is reflection of AA in KK, then we need that ∠D′K′A′=90∘\angle D'K'A' = 90^\circ.
Reflecting in BCBC, this is the same as proving ∠AK′′D′=90∘\angle AK''D' = 90^\circ which is the same as Claim 0.7 in the preliminaries. Thus, we are done.
□\square

Solution A3
The following proof is due to ideas from Adhitya MV in the TST. The proof has been revised and rewritten by the Problem Selection Committee.
We claim that PP is the midpoint of AD′AD'.

Claim 1 It is sufficient to prove that ∠PKD=90∘\angle PKD = 90^\circ.
Proof. Same as Claim 1 in Solution A2
Now, let R=KP∩ADR = KP \cap AD. Now, it suffices to prove that ∠RKD=90∘\angle RKD = 90^\circ. Now, ∠SKA=90∘\angle SKA = 90^\circ by Claim 0.6 from preliminaries. Thus, we just need ∠RKA=∠SKD\angle RKA = \angle SKD. But (SDKA)(SDKA) is cyclic. Thus, ∠SKD=∠SAD=∠SAR\angle SKD = \angle SAD = \angle SAR.
Thus, we just need to show that circles Ω\Omega and (SAK)(SAK) are tangent. Thus, we just need that reflection of AA in RR is on Ω\Omega. Taking homothety +2+2 from AA, we need AD∩K′D′∈ΩAD \cap K'D' \in \Omega.
Let R′=AD∩ΩR' = AD \cap \Omega.
Now, projecting (BC;DD′)(BC; DD') onto Ω\Omega from R′R', we get that (B,C;A,D′R′∩Ω)=−1(B, C; A, D'R' \cap \Omega) = -1 but (B,C;A,K′)=−1  ⟹  D′R′∩Ω=K′(B, C; A, K') = -1 \implies D'R' \cap \Omega = K'. Thus, R′R' is the reflection of AA in RR as required.

We claim that PP is the midpoint of AD′AD'.
Claim 1 It is sufficient to prove that ∠PKD=90∘\angle PKD = 90^\circ.
Proof. Same as Claim 1 in Solution A2
Now, reflecting figure in BCBC and taking homothety 12\frac{1}{2} from AA, we have △ABC↦△DLN\triangle ABC \mapsto \triangle DLN, K′′↦KK'' \mapsto K and D′↦PD' \mapsto P. Thus, KK is the DD-HM point in △DLN\triangle DLN and PP is the point such that (K,L;P,AD∩LN)=−1(K, L; P, AD \cap LN) = -1. But then by Claim 0.7 from preliminaries, we get that ∠PKD=90∘\angle PKD = 90^\circ and we are done.

The following proof is due to ideas from Atul Shatavart Nadig in the TST. The proof has been revised and rewritten by the Problem Selection Committee.
We claim that PP is point of intersection of XYXY and perpendicular bisector of ADAD.
Let QQ be the foot of perpendicular from PP onto BCBC, and let NN be the midpoint of AMAM. Since K′′K'' lies on AMAM by Claim 0.5, taking reflection in BCBC, we get A′,K′A', K', MM collinear, and hence taking homothety with center AA and ratio 12\frac{1}{2}, we get that D,K,ND, K, N are collinear.
We already know PA=PDPA = PD. Note that PX⋅PY=powω(P)=PM2−MB2PX \cdot PY = \text{pow}_\omega(P) = PM^2 - MB^2. So it suffices to show
PD2=PM2−MB2  ⟺  MB2=PM2−PD2 PD^2 = PM^2 - MB^2 \\ \iff MB^2 = PM^2 - PD^2
By the Pythagorean Theorem, since PQ⊥DMPQ \perp DM,
PM2−PD2=QM2−QD2=(QM−QD)(QM+QD)=DM⋅(2QD+DM) \begin{aligned} PM^2 - PD^2 &= QM^2 - QD^2 \\ &= (QM - QD)(QM + QD) \\ &= DM \cdot (2QD + DM) \end{aligned}
Let x=QDx = QD. Thus we need to show
MB2=DM⋅(2x+DM)  ⟺  x=MB2−DM22DM  ⟺  x+DM2=MB22DM \begin{aligned} MB^2 &= DM \cdot (2x + DM) \\ \iff x &= \frac{MB^2 - DM^2}{2DM} \\ \iff x + \frac{DM}{2} &= \frac{MB^2}{2DM} \end{aligned}
Let RR be the midpoint of ADAD. By midpoint theorem, RN=DM2RN = \frac{DM}{2}, so x+DM2=PR+RN=PNx + \frac{DM}{2} = PR + RN = PN. So it suffices to prove that
PN=MB22DM PN = \frac{MB^2}{2DM}
Let ∠PND=∠NDM=∠NMD=θ\angle PND = \angle NDM = \angle NMD = \theta. Then
PNcos⁡θ=NK=MK′2  ⟹  PN=MK′2cos⁡θ PN \cos \theta = NK = \frac{MK'}{2} \implies PN = \frac{MK'}{2 \cos \theta}

But since K′K' is the A'-HM point in △ABC\triangle ABC, MK′⋅MA′=MB2MK' \cdot MA' = MB^2. So,
PN=MB22MA′cos⁡θ=MB22MAcos⁡θ PN = \frac{MB^2}{2MA' \cos \theta} = \frac{MB^2}{2MA \cos \theta}
But in △AMD\triangle AMD, ∠D=90∘\angle D = 90^\circ and ∠AMD=θ\angle AMD = \theta, so cos⁡θ=DMAM\cos \theta = \frac{DM}{AM}. Therefore
PN=MB22MA⋅DMAM=MB22DM PN = \frac{MB^2}{2MA \cdot \frac{DM}{AM}} = \frac{MB^2}{2DM}
as required, so we are done. □\square

## Solution B
For the following two solutions, we begin by inverting from AA with radius ∣AB∣∣AC∣\sqrt{|AB||AC|} and reflecting across the AA angle bisector. Let this transformation be Φ\Phi and we write Z↦Z∗Z \mapsto Z^* for any point ZZ under this transformation.
Observe the following maps:
∙B↦C \bullet B \mapsto C
∙C↦B \bullet C \mapsto B
∙K↦K∗\bullet K \mapsto K^* such that K∗BACK^*BAC is a parallelogram.
∙X↦X∗ \bullet X \mapsto X^*
∙Y↦Y∗ \bullet Y \mapsto Y^*
∙D↦D∗\bullet D \mapsto D^* such D∗D^* is the antipode of AA in Ω\Omega.
∙ω↦ω∗\bullet \omega \mapsto \omega^* where ω∗\omega^* is centered at TT and passes through B,CB, C.
Now,
AX⋅DY=AY⋅DX  ⟺  AB⋅ACAX∗⋅AB⋅AC⋅D∗Y∗AD∗AY∗=AB⋅ACAY∗⋅AB⋅AC⋅D∗X∗AD∗AX∗  ⟺  X∗D∗=Y∗D∗ AX \cdot DY = AY \cdot DX \iff \frac{AB \cdot AC}{AX^*} \cdot \frac{AB \cdot AC \cdot D^*Y^*}{AD^*AY^*} = \frac{AB \cdot AC}{AY^*} \cdot \frac{AB \cdot AC \cdot D^*X^*}{AD^*AX^*} \iff X^*D^* = Y^*D^*
Let (AX∗Y∗K∗)=ω1(AX^*Y^*K^*) = \omega_1. Let O1O_1 be the center of ω1\omega_1. Now, we have that XYXY is the common chord of ω1\omega_1 and ω∗\omega^*. Thus, we just want that D∗∈O1TD^* \in O_1T.
Now, we know that XY⊥DKXY \perp DK, thus ω∗\omega^* and (AD∗K∗)(AD^*K^*) are orthogonal. Thus, O1O_1 is the intersection of the D∗D^* and K∗K^* tangents to (AD∗K∗)(AD^*K^*). Thus, we want that D∗TD^*T is the symmedian in △AD∗K∗\triangle AD^*K^*. This is equivalent to ∠AD∗M=∠K∗D∗T\angle AD^*M = \angle K^*D^*T.

### Solution B1
We relabel the points, call D∗D^*, A′A' and call K∗K′K^*K'.
Now, we just want ∠AA′T=∠K′A′M\angle AA'T = \angle K'A'M. Let HH be the orthocenter of △ABC\triangle ABC. Then ∠K′A′M=∠AHM\angle K'A'M = \angle AHM by reflection over MM. Taking homothety half from A′A', ∠AHM=∠OMA′\angle AHM = \angle OMA'.
Thus, we just want ∠OMA′=∠OA′T\angle OMA' = \angle OA'T but this simply follows from the fact that OM⋅OT=OA′2OM \cdot OT = OA'^2. □\square

The following proof is due to ideas from Vedant Saini in the TST. The proof has been revised and rewritten by the Problem Selection Committee.
We now provide a complex bash solution to the required angle condition.
Let A,B,CA, B, C be on the unit circle. Then m=b+c2m = \frac{b+c}{2}, k∗=b+c−ak^* = b+c-a, d∗=−ad^* = -a. t=2bcb+ct = \frac{2bc}{b+c}.

We now want that a−d∗m−d∗⋅k∗−d∗t−d∗∈R\frac{a-d^*}{m-d^*} \cdot \frac{k^*-d^*}{t-d^*} \in \mathbb{R}.
a−d∗m−d∗⋅k∗−d∗t−d∗=2ab+c+2a2⋅b+c2bc+ab+acb+c=4a(b+c)2(b+c+2a)(2bc+ab+ac)=4a(b+c)2a2b2c2(2bc+ab+ac)(2a+b+c)a2b2c2a−d∗m−d∗⋅k∗−d∗t−d∗=4a(1b+1c)2(2a+2b+2c)(2bc+1ab+1ac)=(a−d∗m−d∗⋅k∗−d∗t−d∗)‾ \begin{aligned} \frac{a-d^*}{m-d^*} \cdot \frac{k^*-d^*}{t-d^*} &= \frac{2a}{\frac{b+c+2a}{2}} \cdot \frac{b+c}{\frac{2bc+ab+ac}{b+c}} = \frac{4a(b+c)^2}{(b+c+2a)(2bc+ab+ac)} = \frac{\frac{4a(b+c)^2}{a^2b^2c^2}}{\frac{(2bc+ab+ac)(2a+b+c)}{a^2b^2c^2}} \\ \\ \frac{a-d^*}{m-d^*} \cdot \frac{k^*-d^*}{t-d^*} &= \frac{\frac{4}{a}\left(\frac{1}{b} + \frac{1}{c}\right)^2}{\left(\frac{2}{a} + \frac{2}{b} + \frac{2}{c}\right)\left(\frac{2}{bc} + \frac{1}{ab} + \frac{1}{ac}\right)} = \overline{\left(\frac{a-d^*}{m-d^*} \cdot \frac{k^*-d^*}{t-d^*}\right)} \end{aligned}
This gives the desired result and we are done. □\square

## Solution C
The following proof is due to ideas from Bhavya Tiwari in the TST. The proof has been revised and rewritten by the Problem Selection Committee.
This is a coordinate bash solution. Take a coordinate system with the midpoint MM of BCBC as the origin, B=(−1,0)B = (-1, 0), C=(1,0)C = (1, 0) and A=(d,h)A = (d, h). Then we get D=(d,0)D = (d, 0).
Claim 1 The point KK has coordinates
(d2(c2+1c2),h2(c2−1c2)) \left( \frac{d}{2} \left( \frac{c^2+1}{c^2} \right) , \frac{h}{2} \left( \frac{c^2-1}{c^2} \right) \right)
where c2=d2+h2c^2 = d^2 + h^2.
Proof. We use complex numbers for this. Let k,a,b,ck, a, b, c denote the complex coordinates of K,A,B,CK, A, B, C respectively. Note that since △KBA∼△KAC\triangle KBA \sim \triangle KAC by AA test, KK is the center of spiral similarity sending BABA to ACAC. Hence,
k−ak−b=k−ck−a  ⟹  k2−2ak+a2=k2−(b+c)k+bc  ⟹  k=bc−a2b+c−2a \begin{aligned} \frac{k-a}{k-b} &= \frac{k-c}{k-a} \\ \implies k^2 - 2ak + a^2 &= k^2 - (b+c)k + bc \\ \implies k &= \frac{bc-a^2}{b+c-2a} \end{aligned}
Putting b=1b=1, c=−1c=-1 and a=d+hia=d+hi, we get
k=a2+12a=a∣a∣2+aˉ2∣a∣2=d(∣a∣2+1)+h(∣a∣2−1)i2∣a∣2 \begin{aligned} k &= \frac{a^2 + 1}{2a} \\ &= \frac{a|a|^2 + \bar{a}}{2|a|^2} \\ &= \frac{d(|a|^2 + 1) + h(|a|^2 - 1)i}{2|a|^2} \end{aligned}
which gives us the required coordinates since c2=∣a∣2c^2 = |a|^2 □\square

Slope of line DKDK is:
h2(c2−1c2)d2(c2+1c2)−d=−hd \frac{\frac{h}{2} \left( \frac{c^2-1}{c^2} \right)}{\frac{d}{2} \left( \frac{c^2+1}{c^2} \right) - d} = -\frac{h}{d}
Therefore slope of XYXY is dh\frac{d}{h} because XY⊥DKXY \perp DK. Therefore, since K∈XYK \in XY, the equation of line XYXY is:
y−h2(c2−1c2)=dh(x−d2(c2+1c2))  ⟹  y=dhx+c2(h2−d2)−h2−d22hc2  ⟹  y=dhx+h2−d2−12h \begin{aligned} y - \frac{h}{2} \left( \frac{c^2 - 1}{c^2} \right) &= \frac{d}{h} \left( x - \frac{d}{2} \left( \frac{c^2 + 1}{c^2} \right) \right) \\ \implies y &= \frac{d}{h}x + \frac{c^2(h^2 - d^2) - h^2 - d^2}{2hc^2} \\ \implies y &= \frac{d}{h}x + \frac{h^2 - d^2 - 1}{2h} \end{aligned}

The problem is equivalent to proving AXDX=AYDY\frac{AX}{DX} = \frac{AY}{DY}. We will in fact prove that AXDX=2=AYDY\frac{AX}{DX} = \sqrt{2} = \frac{AY}{DY}. We will only prove the first equality, as the other one follows from symmetry. Let X=(x1,x2)X = (x_1, x_2). Note that XX satisfies equation of line XYXY. Thus:
AXDX=2⇔AX2DX2=2⇔(x1−d)2+(x2−h)2(x1−d)2+h2=2⇔x12−2dx1+d2+x22−2x2h+h2=0 \begin{aligned} \frac{AX}{DX} &= \sqrt{2} \\ \Leftrightarrow \frac{AX^2}{DX^2} &= 2 \\ \Leftrightarrow \frac{(x_1 - d)^2 + (x_2 - h)^2}{(x_1 - d)^2 + h^2} &= 2 \\ \Leftrightarrow x_1^2 - 2dx_1 + d^2 + x_2^2 - 2x_2h + h^2 &= 0 \end{aligned}
Putting x2x_2 obtained from equation of XYXY into the above, we get that it is equivalent to:
x12−2dx1+d2+(dhx1+h2−d2−12h)2+2h(dhx1+h2−d2−12h)−h2=0⇔(1+d2h2x1)+d(h2−d2−1)h2x1+(h2−d2−12h)2−1=0⇔x12+(d2h2x1+2dh(h2−d2−12h)x1+(h2−d2−12h)2)=1⇔x12+(dhx1+h2−d2−12h)2=1⇔x12+x22=1 \begin{aligned} x_1^2 - 2dx_1 + d^2 + \left(\frac{d}{h}x_1 + \frac{h^2 - d^2 - 1}{2h}\right)^2 &+ 2h\left(\frac{d}{h}x_1 + \frac{h^2 - d^2 - 1}{2h}\right) - h^2 = 0 \\ \Leftrightarrow \left(1 + \frac{d^2}{h^2}x_1\right) + \frac{d(h^2 - d^2 - 1)}{h^2}x_1 &+ \left(\frac{h^2 - d^2 - 1}{2h}\right)^2 - 1 = 0 \\ \Leftrightarrow x_1^2 + \left(\frac{d^2}{h^2}x_1 + 2\frac{d}{h}\left(\frac{h^2 - d^2 - 1}{2h}\right)x_1 + \left(\frac{h^2 - d^2 - 1}{2h}\right)^2\right) &= 1 \\ \Leftrightarrow x_1^2 + \left(\frac{d}{h}x_1 + \frac{h^2 - d^2 - 1}{2h}\right)^2 &= 1 \\ \Leftrightarrow x_1^2 + x_2^2 &= 1 \end{aligned}
because (x1,x2)(x_1, x_2) satisfies equation of XYXY. But the final equation is precisely the equation of the circle with diameter BCBC, which is satisfied by the points XYXY. Hence, all the implications holds, and we are done. □\square

## Supplementary
We can in fact prove that AXDX=AYDY=2\frac{AX}{DX} = \frac{AY}{DY} = \sqrt{2}. Let U,VU, V be points on BCBC such that DU=DA=DVDU = DA = DV. Observe that the circle centered at A′A' (reflection of AA in BCBC) passing through U,VU, V is Appolonius circle for ratio 2\sqrt{2} wrt A,DA, D. Let this circle be ω1\omega_1.
Thus, we just want X,YX, Y to be on this circle. But X,YX, Y also lies on (BC)(BC). Observe that A′M∥KDA'M \parallel KD as proven in Claim 0.5 of the preliminaries.
Thus, the line joining the centers of ω1\omega_1 and (BC)(BC) is perpendicular to XYXY. Thus, we if can find a point PP on XYXY such that powω1(P)=pow(BC)(P)\text{pow}_{\omega_1}(P) = \text{pow}_{(BC)}(P), we will be done, since the radical axis of (BC)(BC) and ω1\omega_1 is parallel to XYXY.
Observe that if we consider the point circle at AA, ω1\omega_1 and (BC)(BC), their radical center is the intersection of the AA-midline of △ABC\triangle ABC and the midline of the polar of AA in (BC)(BC). Thus, we just want the perpendicular bisector of AD,XYAD, XY and the midline of the polar of AA in (BC)(BC) to concur.
This is exactly what we show in Solution A1! Thus, we are done. □\square

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,604 problems in a working order, from Junior Challenge level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.