GeometryDifficulty 6.2National OlympiadProve itUnited States
Problem:
Alan draws a convex 2020-gon A=A1A2⋯A2020 with vertices in clockwise order and chooses 2020 angles θ1,θ2,…,θ2020∈(0,π) in radians with sum 1010π. He then constructs isosceles triangles △AiBiAi+1 on the exterior of A with BiAi=BiAi+1 and ∠AiBiAi+1=θi. (Here, A2021=A1.) Finally, he erases A and the point B1. He then tells Jason the angles θ1,θ2,…,θ2020 he chose. Show that Jason can determine where B1 was from the remaining 2019 points, i.e. show that B1 is uniquely determined by the information Jason has.
Solution
Solution:
For each i, let τi be the transformation of the plane which is rotation by θi counterclockwise about Bi. Recall that a composition of rotations is a rotation or translation, and that the angles of rotation add. Consider the composition τ2020∘τ2019∘⋯∘τ1, with total rotation angle 1010π. This must be a translation because 1010π=505(2π). Also note that the composition sends A1 to itself because τi(Ai)=Ai+1. Therefore it is the identity. Now Jason can identify the map τ1 as τ2−1∘τ3−1∘⋯∘τ2020−1, and B1 is the unique fixed point of this map.
Solution 2:
Fix an arbitrary coordinate system. For 1≤k≤2020, let ak,bk be the complex numbers corresponding to Ak,Bk. The given condition translates to
Summing over all k, and using the fact that e−i(θ1+⋯+θ2020)=1, we see that the right hand side cancels to 0, thus k=1∑2020(e−i(θk−1+⋯+θ1)−e−i(θk+⋯+θ1))bk=0.
Jason knows b2,…,b2020 and all the θi, so the equation above is a linear equation in b1. We finish by noting that the coefficient of b1 is 1−e−iθ1 which is non-zero, as θ1∈(0,π). Thus Jason can solve for b1 uniquely.
Solution 3:
Let A1A2⋯A2020 and A~1A~2⋯A~2020 be two 2020-gons that satisfy the conditions in the problem statement, and let Bk,B~k be the points Alan would construct with respect to these two polygons. It suffices to show that if Bk=B~k for k=2,3,…,2020, then B1=B~1. For 2≤k≤2020, we note that
AkBk=Ak+1Bk,A~kBk=A~k+1Bk
Furthermore, we have the equality of directed angles ∠AkBkAk+1=∠A~kBkA~k+1=θk, therefore ∠AkBkA~k=∠Ak+1BkA~k+1. This implies the congruence △AkBkA~k≅△Ak+1BkA~k+1. The congruence shows that AkA~k=Ak+1A~k+1; furthermore, the angle from the directed segment AkA~k to Ak+1A~k+1 is θk counterclockwise. This holds for k=2,3,…,2020; we conclude that A1A~1=A2A~2, and the angle from the directed segments A1A~1 to A2A~2 is
−k=2∑2020θk=θ1−1010π=θ1 counterclockwise.
Finally we observe that A1B1=A2B1, and the angle from the directed segment A1B1 to A2B1 is θ1 counterclockwise. This implies ∠B1A1A~1=∠B1A2A~2, so △A1B1A~1≅△A2B1A~2. Thus A~1B1=A~2B1, and the angle from A~1B1 to A~2B1 is θ1 counterclockwise. We conclude that B1=B~1.
Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track
puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.
Source: MathNet,
licensed CC-BY-4.0.
Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.