Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / China-TST-B /2 of 6

China-TST-B

Number theory Difficulty 8.5 Shortlist Prove it China

Given a prime number pp and a positive real number λ\lambda less than 11. Let kk be an integer, and let SS and TT be sets consisting of consecutive ss and tt integers, respectively, satisfying 1≤s≤t<λ12p1 \le s \le t < \frac{\lambda}{12}p. Furthermore, assume that the number of elements in the set
{(x,y)∈S×T:kx≡y(modp)} \{(x, y) \in S \times T : kx \equiv y \pmod{p}\}
is not less than 1+λs1 + \lambda s. Prove that there exist integers aa and bb satisfying
ka≡b(modp),0<a≤1λ,∣b∣≤tλs. ka \equiv b \pmod{p}, \quad 0 < a \le \frac{1}{\lambda}, \quad |b| \le \frac{t}{\lambda s}.

Solution

Proof. Let the solutions to the congruence equation kx≡y(modp)kx \equiv y \pmod{p} in S×TS \times T be (x1,y1),…,(xn,yn)(x_1, y_1), \dots, (x_n, y_n), where n≥1+λs≥1n \ge 1 + \lambda s \ge 1. Hence, we know that SS and TT are both non-empty, implying that n≥2n \ge 2. Since TT is contained in a complete residue system modulo pp, we know that the xix_i's are distinct. Without loss of generality, let's assume x1<x2<⋯<xnx_1 < x_2 < \dots < x_n. Let ui=xi−x1u_i = x_i - x_1 and vi=yi−y1v_i = y_i - y_1. Then we have
kui≡vi(modp),0≤ui≤s,∣vi∣≤t. ku_i \equiv v_i \pmod{p}, \quad 0 \le u_i \le s, \quad |v_i| \le t.
Let a=u2gcd⁡(u2,v2)a = \frac{u_2}{\gcd(u_2, v_2)} and b=v2gcd⁡(u2,v2)b = \frac{v_2}{\gcd(u_2, v_2)}. Thus, gcd⁡(a,b)=1\gcd(a, b) = 1, and we have
0<a≤s,∣b∣≤t,ka≡b(modp). 0 < a \le s, \quad |b| \le t, \quad ka \equiv b \pmod{p}.
Combining with kui≡vi(modp)ku_i \equiv v_i \pmod{p}, we obtain
bui≡kaui≡avi(modp). bu_i \equiv kau_i \equiv av_i \pmod{p}.
Let bui=avi+pwibu_i = av_i + pw_i. Then we have
∣wi∣≤∣b∣s+atp. |w_i| \le \frac{|b|s + at}{p}.
Let L=∣b∣s+atpL = \frac{|b|s + at}{p}.

(1) If L<1L < 1, then wi=0w_i = 0 for all ii, and hence bui=avibu_i = av_i. Since gcd⁡(a,b)=1\gcd(a, b) = 1, it follows that uiu_i must be multiples of aa. Combining with the fact that ui∈[0,s]u_i \in [0, s] are distinct non-negative integers, we have
s≥max⁡ui≥a(n−1)≥aλs, s \ge \max u_i \ge a(n-1) \ge a\lambda s,
which implies a≤1λa \le \frac{1}{\lambda}. Furthermore, from
at≥max⁡∣avi∣=max⁡∣bui∣≥∣b∣⋅(aλs), at \ge \max |av_i| = \max |bu_i| \ge |b| \cdot (a\lambda s),
we have ∣b∣≤tλs|b| \le \frac{t}{\lambda s}.

(2) If L≥1L \ge 1, then wiw_i can take at most 2L+1≤3L2L+1 \le 3L integer values in the range [−L,L][-L, L]. By the pigeonhole principle, at least n3L\frac{n}{3L} of the wiw_i's take the same value. Let EE be the set of indices ii where wiw_i takes the same value, and let ui0u_{i_0} be the smallest value in {ui:i∈E}\{u_i : i \in E\}. From
b(ui−ui0)=a(vi−vi0)+p(wi−wi0)=a(vi−vi0),∀i∈E, b(u_i - u_{i_0}) = a(v_i - v_{i_0}) + p(w_i - w_{i_0}) = a(v_i - v_{i_0}), \quad \forall i \in E,
we obtain a∣ui−ui0a \mid u_i - u_{i_0}. Combining 0≤ui−ui0=xi−xi0≤s0 \le u_i - u_{i_0} = x_i - x_{i_0} \le s, we have
s≥max⁡i∈E(ui−ui0)≥a(∣E∣−1). s \ge \max_{i \in E} (u_i - u_{i_0}) \ge a(|E| - 1).
Also, from ∣vi−vi0∣=∣yi−yi0∣≤t|v_i - v_{i_0}| = |y_i - y_{i_0}| \le t, we have
at≥max⁡(a∣vi−vi0∣)=∣b∣max⁡i∈E(ui−ui0)≥∣b∣(a(∣E∣−1)). at \ge \max (a|v_i - v_{i_0}|) = |b| \max_{i \in E} (u_i - u_{i_0}) \ge |b|(a(|E| - 1)).
Note that
L=∣b∣s+atp≤2stp<λs6, L = \frac{|b|s + at}{p} \le \frac{2st}{p} < \frac{\lambda s}{6},
which implies 1<λs6L1 < \frac{\lambda s}{6L}. Thus, we have
∣E∣−1≥λs3L−λs6L=λs6L. |E| - 1 \ge \frac{\lambda s}{3L} - \frac{\lambda s}{6L} = \frac{\lambda s}{6L}.
Substituting back into the previous inequalities, we obtain
λa≤6L,λ∣b∣s≤6Lt, \lambda a \le 6L, \quad \lambda |b|s \le 6Lt,
which leads to
λp=λ∣b∣s+λatL≤12t, \lambda p = \frac{\lambda |b|s + \lambda at}{L} \le 12t,
contradicting the condition t<λp12t < \frac{\lambda p}{12}!

Thus, we have shown that L≥1L \ge 1 is not possible, and only L<1L < 1 holds true in this case. □\square

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,604 problems in a working order, from Junior Challenge level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.