Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / China-TST-A /4 of 9

China-TST-A

Algebra Difficulty 8.5 Shortlist Prove it China

Given a positive integer kk, let integers a,ba, b (not both zero) satisfy 0≤a<k0 \le a < k, 0≤b<k+10 \le b < k+1. Define the sequence {Tn}n≥k\{T_n\}_{n \ge k} as follows:
Tk=a,Tk+1=b, T_k = a, \quad T_{k+1} = b,
and for n≥k+2n \ge k + 2,
Tn≡Tn−1+Tn−2(modn)with0≤Tn<n. T_n \equiv T_{n-1} + T_{n-2} \pmod{n} \quad \text{with} \quad 0 \le T_n < n.
Concatenating the decimal expansions of Tk,Tk+1,…T_k, T_{k+1}, \dots after the decimal point yields an infinite decimal x=0.TkTk+1…x = 0.T_kT_{k+1}\dots. For example, if k=66k = 66, a=5a = 5, b=20b = 20, then T66=5T_{66} = 5, T67=20T_{67} = 20, T68=25T_{68} = 25, T69=45T_{69} = 45, T70=0T_{70} = 0, T71=45T_{71} = 45, T72=45T_{72} = 45, T73=17T_{73} = 17, etc., so x=0.52025450454517…x = 0.52025450454517\dots.
Prove that xx is irrational.

Solution

Proof: First, we prove that {Tn}n=k∞\{T_n\}_{n=k}^{\infty} is unbounded. If not, let M=max⁡n≥k{Tn}M = \max_{n \ge k}\{T_n\}, then for any n>2Mn > 2M, from Tn−1≤MT_{n-1} \le M and Tn−2≤MT_{n-2} \le M, we have Tn=Tn−1+Tn−2T_n = T_{n-1} + T_{n-2}. By the boundedness of TnT_n, the only possibility is Tn−1=Tn−2=0T_{n-1} = T_{n-2} = 0, which inductively leads to Tk+1=Tk=0T_{k+1} = T_k = 0, a contradiction!

Let m0m_0 be the number of digits of kk. We further prove that for any m>m0m > m_0, there exists nn such that 10m−1≤Tn<10m10^{m-1} \le T_n < 10^m. By the unboundedness of TnT_n, there exists a minimal Tn≥10m−1T_n \ge 10^{m-1}, then n>k+1n > k+1 and Tn−1,Tn−2<10m−1T_{n-1}, T_{n-2} < 10^{m-1}, thus Tn≤Tn−1+Tn−2<2⋅10m−1<10mT_n \le T_{n-1} + T_{n-2} < 2 \cdot 10^{m-1} < 10^m.

For convenience, denote p⋆qp \star q as the number obtained by concatenating positive integer pp with non-negative integer qq. By contradiction, assume 0.Tk⋆Tk+1⋆⋯=0.a1…asb1…btb1…bt…0.T_k \star T_{k+1} \star \dots = 0.a_1 \dots a_s b_1 \dots b_t b_1 \dots b_t \dots (i.e., this repeating decimal has ultimate period length tt), where ai,bj∈{0,1,…,9}a_i, b_j \in \{0, 1, \dots, 9\}. Take nn sufficiently large so that TnT_n appears to the right of asa_s, then for any r≥nr \ge n, Tr⋆Tr+1⋆Tr+2…T_r \star T_{r+1} \star T_{r+2} \dots is a number with period wtwt, where ww is any positive integer. Take m=νtm = \nu t with ν\nu sufficiently large so that 10m−1>Ti10^{m-1} > T_i for all i≤ni \le n, then there exists a minimal ℓ\ell such that TℓT_\ell has exactly mm digits, clearly ℓ>n\ell > n.

If Tℓ−1T_{\ell-1} has more than mm digits, then there must exist j<ℓ−1j < \ell - 1 where TjT_j has m−1m-1 digits, leading to some number before TℓT_\ell having mm digits, a contradiction!

Clearly k≠mk \ne m, so k<mk < m. But mm is the period length, thus the last kk digits of Tℓ−1T_{\ell-1} and TℓT_\ell must be identical, which implies Tℓ−2T_{\ell-2} has at least mm digits. Therefore, there exists a number before Tℓ−1T_{\ell-1} with mm digits, another contradiction!

In conclusion, the assumption by contradiction is invalid, and the original proposition is proved. □

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,604 problems in a working order, from Junior Challenge level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.