Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /2 of 11

Combinatorics Difficulty 8.3 Shortlist Prove it United States

For a finite simple graph GG, we define GG' to be the graph on the same vertex set as GG, where for any two vertices uvu \neq v, the pair {u,v}\{u, v\} is an edge of GG' if and only if uu and vv have a common neighbor in GG. Prove that if GG is a finite simple graph which is isomorphic to (G)(G')', then GG is also isomorphic to GG'.

We say a vertex of a graph is fatal if it has degree at least 3, and some two of its neighbors are not adjacent.

Solution

Claim — The graph GG' has at least as many triangles as GG, and has strictly more if GG has any fatal vertices.
Proof. Obviously any triangle in GG persists in GG'. Moreover, suppose vv is a fatal vertex of GG. Then the neighbors of GG will form a clique in GG' which was not there already, so there are more triangles. \square

Thus we only need to consider graphs GG with no fatal vertices. Looking at the connected components, the only possibilities are cliques (including single vertices), cycles, and paths. So in what follows we restrict our attention to graphs GG only consisting of such components.

Remark (Warning). Beware: assuming GG is connected loses generality. For example, it could be that G=G1G2G = G_1 \sqcup G_2, where G1G2G_1' \cong G_2 and G2G1G_2' \cong G_1.

First, note that the following are stable under the operation:
* an isolated vertex,
* a cycle of odd length, or
* a clique with at least three vertices.

In particular, GGG \cong G'' holds for such graphs.

On the other hand, cycles of even length or paths of nonzero length will break into more connected components. For this reason, a graph GG with any of these components will not satisfy GGG \cong G'' because GG' will have strictly more connected components than GG, and GG'' will have at least as many as GG'.

Therefore GGG \cong G'' if and only if GG is a disjoint union of the three types of connected components named earlier. Since GGG \cong G' holds for such graphs as well, the problem statement follows right away.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.