Someone has written the numbers , , , on a chalkboard. In each step, we choose two (not necessarily different) numbers on the chalkboard such that one divides the other. We then erase these two numbers and write their quotient, which is a natural number, on the chalkboard. We repeat the process until there is a pair of numbers on the chalkboard such that one of the numbers divides the other. At least how many numbers stay written on the chalkboard?
, 2012
Solution
Let be the product of all the numbers on the chalkboard after the k step we choose the numbers such that divides , then
Thus, after each step, the product of all the numbers on the chalkboard is divisible by a square of a natural number. That is, the parity of the exponents in the prime factorization of the product of all the numbers on the chalkboard does not change. Because at the beginning the product is
the product of all the numbers that stay on the chalkboard is a multiple of the number . Since the prime numbers , , , and do not divide any other number on the chalkboard, they stay on the chalkboard till the end. The product of all the other numbers on the chalkboard at the end is at least . Thus, at the end, there must be two additional prime numbers that are greater than on the chalkboard. Altogether there must be at least such prime numbers.
We can get numbers in the described process as follows. First successively erase the following pairs:
, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Then erase all the ones to get the numbers , , , , , , .