Problem:
Does there exist positive integers , and a prime such that
Problem:
Does there exist positive integers , and a prime such that
Solution:
The given equality may be written as
Since , it follows from (1) that
(2) .
Now consider two cases:
1. , and
2. is an odd prime.
Case 1: . Then (1) becomes
(3) :
In view of (2) and (3), it must be or . If , then substituting
in (3) we obtain
which is impossible since is an even integer.
If , then substituting in (3) we get
which is obviously impossible.
Case 2: is an odd prime. Then (1) yields . This together with the facts that
is a prime and that by (2) , yields .
If , then substituting in (1) we obtain
which is impossible since is an odd integer.
If , then substituting in (1) we obtain
whence it follows that
and hence
Since for each odd prime and , it follows that the congruence (5) is not satisfied for any odd prime .
If , then substituting in (1) we obtain
whence it follows that is an odd integer such that
whence since for each odd prime , we have
However, since for each odd integer , it follows that the congruence (6) is not satisfied for any odd integer .
If , then substituting in (1) we obtain
i.e.,
(7)
If , then , and thus (7) cannot be satisfied for any positive integer . If , then becomes
which is obviously not satisfied for any positive integer .
Hence, there does not exist positive integers , and a prime such that .