Problem:
Let be a positive integer and a positive divisor of . Show that if
is an integer, then it is equal to .
, 2022
Solutions — 2
Solution 1
Solution:
Assume that the fraction is an integer, write
Obviously is going to be positive, as both and are also positive. Since divides , we can write . Plugging it into the above equation we get
So also divides , we can write for ( if and only if ). Plugging that in again, gives us
As , we have . Now assume . From this it would follow that is strictly positive, leading to . Under this assumption we would get , leading to
which is impossible. Contradiction! So we must have leading to as wanted.
Solution 2
Solution:
Write as before, and we obtain that . As implies we get
As by Euclid's Algorithm, we also get
This follows as and implies . We do a case distinction on the size of
- If , we have which implies
This is impossible
- If , we instead have . As implies we also have . We get which is also impossible.
- The final case gives us . Then , which means that the fraction is equal to one
Note that in the first two cases we used implies , if both . This finishes the proof.