Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /63 of 63

, 2019

Combinatorics Difficulty 9.2 IMO level Prove it Turkey

For positive integer kk, let
Rn={k,(k1),,1,1,,k1,k} for n=2k and R_n = \{-k, -(k-1), \dots, -1, 1, \dots, k-1, k\} \text{ for } n = 2k \text{ and}
Rn={k,(k1),,1,0,1,,k1,k} for n=2k+1. R_n = \{-k, -(k-1), \dots, -1, 0, 1, \dots, k-1, k\} \text{ for } n = 2k+1.
A device consists of several balls and red or white ropes connecting some ball pairs. A labeling is a coloring of each ball by one of the elements of RnR_n. We say that a labeling is good if colors of any two connected balls are different. We say that a labeling is sensitive if the colors of any two balls connected by white rope are different and the sum of colors of any two balls connected by red rope is not equal to 00.
Let n3n \ge 3 be fixed. Suppose that any device which has a good labeling by RnR_n has also a sensitive labeling by RmR_m. Find the smallest possible value of m=m(n)m = m(n).

Solution

Answer: m=2n1m = 2n-1.
Let us show that if a device has a good labeling by RnR_n then it has a sensitive labeling by RmR_m, where m=2n1m = 2n-1. In
Rm=R2n1={(n1),(n2),,1,0,1,,n2,n1} R_m = R_{2n-1} = \{-(n-1), -(n-2), \dots, -1, 0, 1, \dots, n-2, n-1\}
there are nn non-negative elements. Any good labeling of the device by these nn non-negative elements will be also a sensitive labeling.

Now we construct a device which has a good labeling by RnR_n and has no sensitive labeling for any m<2n1m < 2n-1. Let us define a grid 2n1×n2n-1 \times n (2n12n-1 lines and nn columns) and place a ball into each cell. Let us connect any two balls belonging to the same line by red rope and any two balls belonging to different lines and different columns by white rope (there is no rope between any two balls from the same column). The device has a good labeling by RnR_n. Indeed, there are nn distinct colors and if we color all balls from the same column identically and balls from different columns differently then we get a good labeling.

Suppose that the device has a sensitive coloring by RmR_m.

Case 1. There is a line all balls of which are differently colored. Since all balls of this line are connected by red ropes, for each kk at most one of the colors {k,k}\{-k, k\} is used. Therefore, the total number of elements in RmR_m with different absolute values should be at least nn and consequently m2n1m \ge 2n-1.

Case 2. Each line contains at least two identically colored balls. Suppose that the repeated color on some two lines are aa and bb. Since any two balls belonging to different lines and different columns are connected by a white rope we get aba \neq b. Therefore, repeated colors of any two lines are different and the total number of different colours is at least 2n12n-1 and consequently m2n1m \ge 2n-1. Done.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic and difficulty added by this site.