Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /5 of 6

, 2020

Geometry Difficulty 8.7 Shortlist Prove it Taiwan

Due to the increasing pandemic situation, the government decides to enforce traffic ban by building nn straight lines (infinite at both directions) as "walls", with no two of them are parallel, and no three of them are concurrent. The set of these walls is denoted as WnW_n. For each wall in WnW_n, the government paints one of its sides in blue, and the other side in green. By such, for any two walls, their intersection is divided into four corners: a mono-color corner such that both walls are blue, a mono-color corner such that both walls are green, and two duel-color corners such that the walls are in different colors. To make sure there are paths for emergency, the government opens a door on each intersection of walls so that people can travel from a duel-color corner to the other duel-color corner. These doors are the only ways for people to cross a wall.
Given WnW_n, let k(Wn)k(W_n) be the largest positive integer kk such that, no matter how the government paints the walls, we can place kk people on the plane so that no two of them can ever meet each other. For each nn, find all possible values of k(Wn)k(W_n).

Solution

For all nn, the only possible value of k(Wn)k(W_n) is k=n+1k = n + 1.

By mathematical induction, it is easy to see that WnW_n divides the plane into C2n+1+1C_2^{n+1} + 1 regions. We convert this problem into a graph GG, where each vertex corresponds to a region, and two regions that can be connected by a door are joined by an edge.

First, we prove that k(Wn)n+1k(W_n) \ge n + 1. Note that the number of intersection points of the walls must be C2nC_2^n, hence the number of edges of GG must be C2nC_2^n. Let us first remove all edges from GG, and then add them back one by one; each time we add back an edge, the number of connected regions in GG decreases by at most one, so the final number of connected regions of GG is at least C2n+1+1C2n=n+1C_2^{n+1} + 1 - C_2^n = n + 1. If we place one person in each connected region, then clearly these people can never meet, hence k(Wn)n+1k(W_n) \ge n + 1.

Next, we prove that, regardless of what WnW_n is, the following coloring method forces us to place at most n+1n + 1 people:
- First, choose a rectangular coordinate system such that no wall is oriented north-south or east-west;
- Paint the west side of each wall green, and the east side blue.

Furthermore, we compute for each wall the eastward value EE = "the number of walls to the east of which this region lies". Clearly EE ranges between 0 and nn, and for each value in this range there is exactly one region with "no wall to its north" corresponding to that EE value. Therefore, if we can prove:

**Claim. All regions with the same EE value are connected to each other.**

then we will have proven that at most n+1n + 1 people can be placed, and thus the original proposition is established.

Proof of Claim.
Fix i{0,,n}i \in \{0, \dots, n\}, and place a person in a region with E=iE = i. Let this person move toward the north. Note that every bounded region is a convex polygon, and its northernmost edge must be an intersection point, which must have a door, so this person must eventually reach a region with no wall to its north. Furthermore, note that when a person passes through a door and arrives at a new region, exactly one wall switches from its east side to its west side, and exactly one wall switches from its west side to its east side, hence the EE value of all regions along this person's path are equal. Therefore, all regions with E=iE = i are connected to the region with no wall to its north and E=iE = i, which completes the proof.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement translated into English from zh; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.