Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /267 of 299

Geometry Difficulty 7.5 National Olympiad, round 2 Prove it Iran

Ali is given a piece of paper shaped like an equilateral triangle. He cuts the paper into two pieces with one cut. Then, he puts the pieces arbitrarily on a table and cuts them both with one cut to get four pieces of paper. Lastly, he puts all four pieces on the table and cuts them all with one cut to get eight pieces. In the end, he will have eight pieces of paper using three cuts.
Ali wants to do this in such a way that in the end, seven pieces are equal to each other but not to the last one.
a) Prove that if seven pieces are equal, then they are either triangles or quadrilaterals.
b) Prove that the seven equal pieces cannot be quadrilaterals.
c) Is it possible for the seven equal pieces to be triangles and not equal to the last one?

Solution

a) Note that every polygon produced during this process is convex. That said, the idea here is to find an upper bound for the sum of angles of them. After cutting a polygon PP into two polygons P1P_1 and P2P_2, three possibilities arise: (σ(Q)(\sigma(Q) denotes the sum of angles of polygon Q)Q)
* The cutting line connects two vertices of PP. In this case σ(P)=σ(P1)+σ(P2)\sigma(P) = \sigma(P_1) + \sigma(P_2).
* The cutting line connects a vertex of PP to an inner point of a side. In this case σ(P1)+σ(P2)=σ(P)+π\sigma(P_1) + \sigma(P_2) = \sigma(P) + \pi.
* The cutting line connects two inner points from two sides of PP. In this case σ(P1)+σ(P2)=σ(P)+2π\sigma(P_1) + \sigma(P_2) = \sigma(P) + 2\pi.
The first polygon is a triangle and the sum of its angles is π\pi. Therefore, after the first cut the sum of angles of the resulting polygons is at most π+2π=3π\pi + 2\pi = 3\pi. After the second cut each of these two polygons are divided into two new polygons. Therefore, after the second cut the sum of angles of these polygons is at most 3π+2×2π=7π3\pi + 2 \times 2\pi = 7\pi. Similarly, after the third cut the sum of angles of the resulting eight polygons is at most 7π+4×2π=15π7\pi + 4 \times 2\pi = 15\pi. Now, if the 7 equal pieces have at least 5 sides, then the sum of angles of each polygon is at least 3π3\pi and the sum of angles of the last piece is at least π\pi. Therefore,
22π=π+7×3πsum of angles of all pieces15π. 22\pi = \pi + 7 \times 3\pi \le \text{sum of angles of all pieces} \le 15\pi.
This contradiction shows that these seven equal pieces must be either triangles or quadrilaterals.

b) According to the previous part, if these equal pieces are quadrilaterals, then the last piece should be a triangle. Furthermore, the cutting line of each polygon connects two inner points from two sides of the polygon. Assuming that such a cutting process is possible, a result is that the seven congruent quadrilaterals cannot be cyclic; because if they are cyclic, one of the following cases happens, and it is easy to show that each case results in a contradiction.

Figure 1
Assuming that the quadrilaterals are not cyclic, it is easy to show that they must be parallelograms. Like before, it is easy to check the resulting case and verify that it is impossible.

c) Yes! Let xx be a very small positive number. Then the cutting process can be done as instructed below:

Figure 2

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.