Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /39 of 41

Geometry Difficulty 7.2 National Olympiad, round 2 Prove it New Zealand

Problem:
Let ABC\triangle ABC be an acute triangle with AB>ACAB > AC. Let PP be the foot of the altitude from CC to ABAB and let QQ be the foot of the altitude from BB to ACAC. Let XX be the intersection of PQPQ and BCBC. Let the intersection of the circumcircles of triangle AXC\triangle AXC and triangle PQC\triangle PQC be distinct points: CC and YY. Prove that PYPY bisects AXAX.

Solution

Solution:
Let ZZ be the point where PYPY intersects AXAX. The problem asks us to prove that AZ=ZXAZ = ZX.

Figure 1

Since BPC=BQC=90\angle BPC = \angle BQC = 90^\circ we conclude that BPQCBPQC is a cyclic quadrilateral. Hence BPYQCBPYQC is a cyclic pentagon. A quick angle chase gives us:

ZPA=180BPY=BCY=180XCY=XAY=ZAY. \angle ZPA = 180^\circ - \angle BPY \\ \qquad = \angle BCY \\ \qquad = 180^\circ - \angle XCY \\ \qquad = \angle XAY \\ \qquad = \angle ZAY.

Hence triangles ZPA\triangle ZPA and ZAY\triangle ZAY are similar (Z\angle Z is shared). Therefore ZPZA=ZAZY\frac{ZP}{ZA} = \frac{ZA}{ZY}, and hence ZA2=ZP×ZYZA^2 = ZP \times ZY.

Another angle chase gives us:

XPZ=QPY=QCY=ACY=AXY=ZXY. \angle XPZ = \angle QPY \\ \qquad = \angle QCY \\ \qquad = \angle ACY \\ \qquad = \angle AXY \\ \qquad = \angle ZXY.

Hence triangles ZPX\triangle ZPX and ZXY\triangle ZXY are similar (Z\angle Z is shared). Therefore ZPZX=ZXZY\frac{ZP}{ZX} = \frac{ZX}{ZY} and hence ZX2=ZP×ZYZX^2 = ZP \times ZY.

Putting this together gives us:

ZA2=ZP×ZY=ZX2. ZA^2 = ZP \times ZY = ZX^2.

Hence ZA=ZXZA = ZX, and therefore ZZ is the midpoint of AXAX.

Alternative Solution (outline):

First we will embed the diagram in the Argand plane, such that point BB is represented by the complex number b=1b = -1 and point CC is represented by the complex number c=1c = 1. Lower case letters will always denote the complex number representing the corresponding upper case letter (so aa is the complex number representing point AA and xx is the complex number representing point XX, etc). We will endeavour to find expressions for all the points in the diagram in terms of pp and qq.

Since BPC=BQC=90\angle BPC = \angle BQC = 90^\circ, we know that points PP and QQ both lie on the unit circle. So ppˉ=qqˉ=1p\bar{p} = q\bar{q} = 1. Therefore the circumcircle of triangle PQCPQC is the unit circle and thus yyˉ=1y\bar{y} = 1 too. Since point AA is the intersection of chords BPBP and CQCQ, we can compute aa using the formula for the intersection of two chords.

a=cq(b+p)bp(c+q)cqbp=q(1+p)(1)p(1+q)q(1)p=2pq+pqp+q a = \frac{cq(b + p) - bp(c + q)}{cq - bp} = \frac{q(-1 + p) - (-1)p(1 + q)}{q - (-1)p} = \frac{2pq + p - q}{p + q}

aˉ=2pˉqˉ+pˉqˉpˉ+qˉ=(2pˉqˉ+pˉqˉ)pq(pˉ+qˉ)pq=2+qpq+p \Rightarrow \qquad \bar{a} = \frac{2\bar{p}\bar{q} + \bar{p} - \bar{q}}{\bar{p} + \bar{q}} = \frac{(2\bar{p}\bar{q} + \bar{p} - \bar{q})pq}{(\bar{p} + \bar{q})pq} = \frac{2 + q - p}{q + p}

note:1a1aˉ=12pq+pqp+q12+qpq+p=(p+q)(2pq+pq)(p+q)(2+qp)=2q2pq2p2=q. \mathrm{note:}\qquad \frac{1 - a}{1 - \bar{a}} = \frac{1 - \frac{2pq + p - q}{p + q}}{1 - \frac{2 + q - p}{q + p}} = \frac{(p + q) - (2pq + p - q)}{(p + q) - (2 + q - p)} = \frac{2q - 2pq}{2p - 2} = -q.

Similarly XX is the intersection of chords PQPQ and BCBC, so

x=pq(b+c)bc(p+q)pqbc=pq(0)(1)(p+q)pq(1)=p+qpq+1 x = \frac{pq(b + c) - bc(p + q)}{pq - bc} = \frac{pq(0) - (-1)(p + q)}{pq - (-1)} = \frac{p + q}{pq + 1}

Now we have formulas for aa and xx in terms of pp and qq. Next we will use the fact that AYCXAYCX is cyclic to find a formula for yy in terms of pp and qq. AYCXAYCX being cyclic is equivalent to CAY=CXY\angle CAY = \angle CXY. This is equivalent to

(cacˉaˉ)/(yayˉaˉ)=(cxcˉxˉ)/(yxyˉxˉ) \left(\frac{c - a}{\bar{c} - \bar{a}}\right) / \left(\frac{y - a}{\bar{y} - \bar{a}}\right) = \left(\frac{c - x}{\bar{c} - \bar{x}}\right) / \left(\frac{y - x}{\bar{y} - \bar{x}}\right)

To simplify this, first recall that cacˉaˉ=1a1aˉ=q\frac{c - a}{\bar{c} - \bar{a}} = \frac{1 - a}{1 - \bar{a}} = -q. Also, since c=cˉc = \bar{c} and x=xˉx = \bar{x} (cc and xx are real numbers) the cxcˉxˉ\frac{c - x}{\bar{c} - \bar{x}} factor is 1. Furthermore, since yyˉ=1y\bar{y} = 1 we can replace yˉ\bar{y} with y1y^{-1}. Thus the equation for AYCXAYCX being cyclic becomes:

(q)/(yay1aˉ)=1/(yxy1x). (-q) / \left(\frac{y - a}{y^{-1} - \bar{a}}\right) = 1 / \left(\frac{y - x}{y^{-1} - x}\right).

From here, we can multiply out the denominators, expand the brackets and collect like terms to get a quadratic in yy.

(qaˉ+x)y2(qaˉx+q+xa+1)y+(qx+a)=0. (q\bar{a} + x)y^2 - (q\bar{a}x + q + xa + 1)y + (qx + a) = 0.

Now (using 1a1aˉ=q\frac{1 - a}{1 - \bar{a}} = -q) we can get (qaˉ+x+qx+a)=(qaˉx+q+xa+1)(q\bar{a} + x + qx + a) = (q\bar{a}x + q + xa + 1). Thus the quadratic factorises as:

(y1)((qaˉ+x)y(qx+a))=0. (y - 1)\Big((q\bar{a} + x)y - (qx + a)\Big) = 0.

Since YY and CC are distinct points, we know y1y \neq 1 and so we finally get a formula for yy

(qaˉ+x)y(qx+a)=0y=qx+aqaˉ+x (q\bar{a} + x)y - (qx + a) = 0\qquad \Longrightarrow \qquad y = \frac{qx + a}{q\bar{a} + x}

We can now substitute our formulas for aa and xx (a=2pq+pqp+qa = \frac{2pq + p - q}{p + q} and x=p+qpq+1x = \frac{p + q}{pq + 1}) into this expression to find yy in terms of pp and qq. After some algebraic simplification this yields:

y=2p2q+(q+1)p+q2q(1q)p2+(q+q2)p+2q. y = \frac{2p^2q + (q + 1)p + q^2 - q}{(1 - q)p^2 + (q + q^2)p + 2q}.

Let MM be the midpoint of AXAX. So

m=a+x2=2pq+pqp+q+p+qpq+12=(pq+1)(2pq+pq)+(p+q)22(p+q)(pq+1). m = \frac{a + x}{2} = \frac{\frac{2pq + p - q}{p + q} + \frac{p + q}{pq + 1}}{2} = \frac{(pq + 1)(2pq + p - q) + (p + q)^2}{2(p + q)(pq + 1)}.

m=(pq+1)(2+qp)+(p+q)22(p+q)(pq+1). \overline{m} = \frac{(pq + 1)(2 + q - p) + (p + q)^2}{2(p + q)(pq + 1)}.

pm1=(p1)((1q)p2+(q+q2)p+2q)2(p+q)(pq+1) p\overline{m} - 1 = \frac{(p - 1)((1 - q)p^2 + (q + q^2)p + 2q)}{2(p + q)(pq + 1)}

y(pm1)=(p1)(2p2q+(q+1)p+q2q)2(p+q)(pq+1) y(p\overline{m} - 1) = \frac{(p - 1)(2p^2q + (q + 1)p + q^2 - q)}{2(p + q)(pq + 1)}

y(pm1)+m=(p1)(2p2q+(q+1)p+q2q)2(p+q)(pq+1)+(pq+1)(2pq+pq)+(p+q)22(p+q)(pq+1) y(p\overline{m} - 1) + m = \frac{(p - 1)(2p^2q + (q + 1)p + q^2 - q)}{2(p + q)(pq + 1)} + \frac{(pq + 1)(2pq + p - q) + (p + q)^2}{2(p + q)(pq + 1)}

=(p1)(2p2q+(q+1)p+q2q)+(pq+1)(2pq+pq)+(p+q)22(p+q)(pq+1) = \frac{(p - 1)(2p^2q + (q + 1)p + q^2 - q) + (pq + 1)(2pq + p - q) + (p + q)^2}{2(p + q)(pq + 1)}

=2p3q+2p2q2+2p2+2pq2(p+q)(pq+1) = \frac{2p^3q + 2p^2q^2 + 2p^2 + 2pq}{2(p + q)(pq + 1)}

=p. = p.

We have shown that y(pm1)+m=py(p\overline{m} - 1) + m = p. Hence

m=p+ypym. m = p + y - py\overline{m}.

Which interpreted geometrically means that point MM lies on chord PYPY of the unit circle.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.