Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /98 of 104

Combinatorics Difficulty 7.0 National Olympiad, round 2 Prove it Bulgaria

Problem:
Let AA be the set of all 4-tuples of 00 and 11. Two such 4-tuples are called neighbors if they coincide exactly at three positions. Let MM be a subset of AA with the following property: any two elements of MM are not neighbors and there exists an element of MM which is neighbor of exactly one of them. Find the minimum possible cardinality of MM.

Solution

Solution:
Consider a table with rows corresponding to the elements of AA and columns corresponding to the elements of MM. We write ×\times in a cell if the element of AA in the respective row is adjacent to the element of MM in the respective column. Let M=k|M| = k. It follows from the given condition that there are no two equal rows, which means that MM has at least 1616 different subsets. Since a set with nn elements has 2n2^{n} subsets, we get k4k \geq 4.

Any row has exactly five adjacent and thus any column contains exactly five ×\times, i.e., the total number of ×\times is 5k5k. A minimal number of ×\times by rows is attained if one row contains no ×\times, kk rows contain one ×\times, (k2)\binom{k}{2} rows contain two ×\times, etc.

If k=4k = 4, then all the subsets of MM are 1616 and hence any subset of MM appears exactly once as an adjacent set to some element of AA. Then we have one row with no ×\times, 44 rows with one ×\times, 66 rows with two ×\times, 44 rows with three ×\times and one row with four ×\times. The total number of ×\times becomes 32>2032 > 20, a contradiction.

For k=5k = 5 one has 2525 ×\times. Their minimal number by rows is attained when one row contains no ×\times, 55 rows contain one ×\times and 1010 rows contain two ×\times. Since 51+102=255 \cdot 1 + 10 \cdot 2 = 25 the distribution of ×\times must be exactly the one described above. This means that any two elements of MM are simultaneously adjacent to some element of AA.

It is easy to see that if two elements of MM do not coincide at at most two positions, then there is no element of AA that is adjacent to them. Hence any two elements of MM do not coincide at one or two positions. If there are two elements which do not coincide at one position, we may assume that they are a=0000a = 0000 and b=1000b = 1000. The adjacent to aa and bb in MM are 00000000 and 10001000. So the rows of aa and bb coincide, a contradiction. This shows that any two elements of MM are different at exactly two positions. We may assume that 0000M0000 \in M. Then the remaining 44 elements are among 00110011, 11001100, 01010101, 10101010, 10011001 and 01100110. But among any of the pairs (0011,1100)(0011, 1100), (0101,1010)(0101, 1010) and (1001,0110)(1001, 0110) at most one element can be chosen, a contradiction.

For k=6k = 6 the set M={0000,1111,0111,0100,1001,0101}M = \{0000, 1111, 0111, 0100, 1001, 0101\} separates any two elements of AA.

Hence the desired minimal number is 66.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.