Let be a circle, and let and be points on a line not intersecting . Given a point on , define a sequences and as follows: is the second intersection of the line with and is the second intersection of the line with . Prove that if for some integer , it happens that for some choice of then for any choice of .
, 2011
Solution
Consider circles and centred at and respectively such that both and are orthogonal to . Let be one of the intersection points of and . Note that must exist because is outside . Then invert the diagram through a circle centred at with any radius. and (the images of and ) are straight lines passing through the centre of (since they are orthogonal and angles between circles are preserved by inversion). passes through the centre of circle and passes through the centre of circle for the same reason. Hence is reflected in line and is the reflection of in the line . Thus where is the angle between the lines and . Thus is equivalent to , for some integer . This means that consecutive terms in the sequence of points are determined by a rotation through a constant angle. Hence this result will be true irrespective of the choice of . There is a one-to-one correspondence between and and hence the same is true if for some positive integer .