The total number of languages used in KAUST is n. For each positive integer k≤n, let Ak be the set of all those people in KAUST who can speak at least k languages; and let Bk be the set of all people P in KAUST with the property that, for any k pairwise different languages (used in KAUST), P can speak at least one of these k languages. Prove that
a. If 2k≥n+1 then Ak⊆Bk;
b. If 2k≤n+1 then Ak⊇Bk.
Solution
Let L be the set of all the languages used in KAUST.
a. Assume 2k≥n+1. Consider P∈Ak, and let LP⊆L be the set of all languages spoken by P. The set LP contains at least k languages.
Let L′⊆L be a set of k languages. We have ∣LP∩L′∣=∣LP∣+∣L′∣−∣LP∪L′∣≥2k−∣L∣=2k−n≥1. This means that LP∩L′=∅ and therefore P can speak at least one language in L′. Hence P∈Bk.
b. Assume 2k≤n+1. Consider P∈Bk, and let LP⊆L be the set of all languages spoken by P and L′=L∖LP. Because there is no language in L′ spoken by P we have ∣L′∣≤k−1. We deduce that ∣LP∣=∣L∣−∣L′∣≥n−(k−1)≥k. This means that P speaks at least k languages and therefore P∈Ak.
Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track
puts 2,604 problems in a working order, from Junior Challenge level to the IMO shortlist.
Source: MathNet,
licensed CC-BY-4.0.
Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.