a) Let a,b∈R be two real numbers, with a<b, and f:[a,b]→R a strict monotone function such that ∫abf(x)dx=0. Show that f(a)⋅f(b)<0.
b) Determine the convergent sequences (an)n≥1 of real numbers, for which there is a strict monotone function f:R→R such that ∫an−1anf(x)dx=∫anan+1f(x)dx,for any n∈N,n≥2.
Solution
a) If f([a,b])⊆[0,∞) or f([a,b])⊆(−∞,0], then m=∣f(2a+b)∣>0, and on one of the intervals (a,2a+b) or (2a+b,b) the inequality ∣f(x)∣>m holds for any x in that interval. Then 0=∫abf(x)dx=∫ab∣f(x)∣dx=∫a2a+b∣f(x)∣dx+∫2a+bb∣f(x)∣dx≥m⋅2b−a>0, which is impossible. It follows that f(a)⋅f(b)<0.
b) We will show that the only sequences of real numbers (an)n≥1 which satisfy the condition in the statement are the constant sequences and the sequences assuming exactly two distinct real values, which become stationary beginning with a certain rank. Obviously, if (an)n≥1 is a constant sequence, with an=a, a∈R, then the sequence is convergent, with limn→∞an=a and ∫akak+1f(x)dx=0, for any k≥1, and any function f:R→R. If {an∣n≥1}={a,b} and there is a rank n0∈N∗ with an=a, for any n≥n0, then (an)n≥1 is convergent, with limn→∞an=a, and there is the function f:R→R defined by f(x)=2x−a−b, which is strict monotone and satisfies the equalities ∫akak+1f(x)dx=0, for any k≥1.
Let (an)n≥1 be a convergent sequence of real numbers for which there is a strict monotone function f:R→R such that ∫a1a2f(x)dx=∫a2a3f(x)dx=⋯=∫anan+1f(x)dx=…
Let I=∫akak+1f(x)dx, for every k≥1, and a=limn→∞an. For a fixed r>0 there is a rank nr≥1, such that an∈(a−r,a+r), for any n≥nr. Since f is strict monotone, if M=max(∣f(a−r)∣,∣f(a+r)∣), then ∣f(x)∣<M, for every x∈(a−r,a+r). Then, for any p∈N∗ we have: p⋅∣I∣=∣p⋅I∣=k=1∑p∫anr+k−1anr+kf(x)dx=∫anranr+pf(x)dx≤∫anranr+p∣f(x)∣dx<∫a−ra+r∣f(x)∣dx≤2r⋅M. It follows that 0≤∣I∣<p2Mr, for any p∈N∗, so that I=0. We show now that card({an∣n∈N∗})≤2. Assuming the opposite, there exist i,j,k∈N∗, with i<j<k such that ai=aj=ak=ai. Then ∫aiajf(x)dx=l=i∑j−1∫alal+1f(x)dx=(j−i)⋅I=0 and, also, ∫ajakf(x)dx=(k−j)⋅I=0, respectively ∫aiakf(x)dx=0. The function f being strict monotone, it follows that f(ai)⋅f(aj)<0, f(ai)⋅f(ak)<0, and f(aj)⋅f(ak)<0. But then (f(ai)⋅f(aj)⋅f(ak))2=(f(ai)⋅f(aj))⋅(f(ai)⋅f(ak))⋅(f(aj)⋅f(ak))<0, which is absurd.
Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track
puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.
Source: MathNet,
licensed CC-BY-4.0.
Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic and difficulty added by this site.