Let k≥3 be an integer and let functions f0,f1,…,fk be defined for positive integers such that fj(1)f0(n+1)fj+1(n+1)=1=i=0∑kfi(n)=fj(n+1)+fj(n)for 0≤j≤k,for n≥1 andfor 0≤j<k and n≥1. Find integers a0,a1,…,ak such that for all n≥1 fk(n+k+1)=i=0∑kaifk(n+i).
Solutions — 2
Solution 1
With m=n+k+1 and j=k+1−i, we obtain for n≥1 fk(n+k+1)=i=0∑k(ik+1)fk(n+i). This shows that ai=(ik+1) are the integers that solve the problem.
Solution 2
Define r=k+12, so that rk+1=2 and let F=1+r+r2+⋯+rk=r−1rk+1−1=r−11. Also define Fn=∑j=0kfk−j(n)rj for integers n≥1, then F1=F. First we would like to show that F⋅Fn=Fn+1 for all n≥1. As F=r−11, this is equivalent to showing that rFn+1=Fn+Fn+1. To prove this, we will use the identity fk(n+1)+fk(n)=2f0(n+1), which is obtained as follows. First observe that the defining recursion for the fj implies fj(n+1)=2i=0∑kfi(n)−i=j∑kfi(n) for all j≥0 and n≥1. In particular, for j=k, we obtain fk(n+1)=2i=0∑kfi(n)−fk(n)=2f0(n+1)−fk(n), as required. Using this identity, we obtain now Fn+Fn+1=j=0∑k(fk−j(n)+fk−j(n+1))rj=(fk(n)+fk(n+1))+j=1∑kfk−j+1(n+1)rj=2f0(n+1)+j=0∑k−1fk−j(n+1)rj+1=j=0∑kfk−j(n+1)rj+1=rFn+1. This proves that F⋅Fn=Fn+1, from which we obtain Fn=Fn for all n≥1. From F=r−11 we get r=FF+1 and so 2=rk+1=(FF+1)k+1. This gives 2Fk+1=(F+1)k+1 and we obtain Fk+1=i=0∑k(ik+1)Fiand soFn+k+1=i=0∑k(ik+1)Fn+i. Because Fn=Fn this can be rewritten as Fn+k+1=i=0∑k(ik+1)Fn+ithat is j=0∑kfk−j(n+k+1)rj=j=0∑ki=0∑k(ik+1)fk−j(n+i)rj. Because the only rational numbers t0,…,tk satisfying t0+t1r+⋯+tkrk=0 are t0=t1=⋯=tk=0 (see Problem 19), by comparing the terms with j=0, we obtain fk(n+k+1)=i=0∑k(ik+1)fk(n+i). This shows that ai=(ik+1) are the integers that solve the problem.
Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track
puts 2,604 problems in a working order, from Junior Challenge level to the IMO shortlist.
Source: MathNet,
licensed CC-BY-4.0.
Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.