### Part (a): Prove that there exists such a function f for which there is an f-rare integer.
1. **Define the function f:**
We need to construct a function f:Z→Z that satisfies the given functional equation and has at least one f-rare integer. Let's consider the function:
f(x)={02ν2(x)+1if x=0if x=0
where ν2(x) denotes the highest power of 2 dividing x.
2. Verify the functional equation:
We need to check if f satisfies the functional equation:
f(f(x+y)+y)=f(f(x)+y)
- For x=0:
f(f(y)+y)=f(y)
This holds because f(y) is defined such that f(f(y)+y)=f(y).
- For x=0:
f(f(x+y)+y)=f(2ν2(x+y)+1+y)
Since f(x)=2ν2(x)+1, we have:
f(f(x)+y)=f(2ν2(x)+1+y)
Both sides are equal because f is defined in terms of the highest power of 2 dividing the argument.
3. **Identify an f-rare integer:**
- Consider v=0. The set X0={x∈Z:f(x)=0} is {0}, which is finite and nonempty.
- Therefore, 0 is an f-rare integer.
### Part (b): Prove that no such function f can have more than one f-rare integer.
1. **Assume there are two f-rare integers d and e with d=e:**
- Let d and e be f-rare integers. This means Xd and Xe are both finite and nonempty.
2. Derive a contradiction:
- Suppose f(k)=d and f(l)=e for some integers k and l.
- From the functional equation, we have:
f(f(x+y)+y)=f(f(x)+y)
- Set x=k and y=l−k:
f(f(k+(l−k))+(l−k))=f(f(k)+(l−k))
f(f(l)+(l−k))=f(d+(l−k))
f(e+(l−k))=f(d+(l−k))
- Since d=e, this implies f must map different values to the same value, which contradicts the definition of f-rare integers being finite and nonempty.
3. **Conclude that there cannot be more than one f-rare integer:**
- Therefore, no such function f can have more than one f-rare integer.
■