For any odd prime and any integer , let denote the remainder when is divided by . We say that is a -sequence, if is a positive integer coprime to , and for . (a) Do there exist infinitely many primes for which there exist -sequences and such that for infinitely many , and for infinitely many ? (b) Do there exist infinitely many primes for which there exist -sequences and such that for all ? (United Kingdom) Answer: Yes, for both parts.
Solution
Fix some odd prime , and let be the smallest positive integer such that ; in other words, is the multiplicative order of 2 modulo . Consider any -sequence . Obviously, and therefore . This yields and therefore for all . It follows that the sum does not depend on and is thus a function of (and ) only; we shall denote this sum by , and extend the function to all (not necessarily positive) integers. Therefore, we have for all positive integers and . Clearly, for every integer . In both parts, we use the notation
(a) Let be a prime and a prime divisor of that is greater than 3. We will show that is suitable for part (a). Notice that , so that such a exists. Moreover, for any two odd primes and , but for every . Now, since , then we can put and . Otherwise, if , then we put and .
This page is intentionally left blank