5. N5 (IRN) Let be positive integers, and let be integers, none of which is a multiple of . Show that there exist integers , not all zero, with for all , such that is a multiple of .
Solution
5. Consider all possible sums , where each is an integer with . There are such sums, and if any two of them give the same remainder modulo , say , then is divisible by , and since , we are done. We claim that two such sums must exist. Suppose to the contrary that the sums give all the different remainders modulo . Consider the polynomial
where the sum is taken over all with . If is a primitive th root of unity, then by the assumption we have
On the other hand, can be factored as
so that none of its factors is zero at because is not divisible by . This is obviously a contradiction. Remark. The example for shows that the condition that no is a multiple of cannot be removed.
Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track
puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.