Let be a function, and let be applied times. Suppose that for every there exists a such that , and let be the smallest such . Prove that the sequence is unbounded.
Solution
We restrict attention to the set
Observe that is unbounded because for every number in there exists a such that is in . Clearly maps into itself; moreover is injective on . Indeed if with then the values start repeating periodically from some point on, and would be finite. Define by . We prove that is injective too. Suppose that with and . So, since is injective on , we obtain
However this contradicts the minimality of as . Therefore, is injective.
Let . Since for , is non-empty. For each denote ; call the chain starting at . Observe that distinct chains are disjoint because is injective. Each has the form with , and . Since , we have , and thus . In conclusion is unbounded.
Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track
puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.