Let be a positive integer. What is the largest for which there exist matrices and with real entries such that for all and , the matrix product has a zero entry somewhere on its diagonal if and only if ?
Solution
The largest such is . We first show that this value can be achieved by an explicit construction. Let be the standard basis of . For , let be the matrix with row vectors , and let be the transpose of . Then has -th diagonal entry , proving the claim. We next show that for any families of matrices as described, we must have . Let be the -fold tensor product} of , i.e., the vector space with orthonormal basis for . Let be the tensor product of the rows of ; that is, Similarly, let be the tensor product of the columns of . One computes easily that equals the product of the diagonal entries of , and so vanishes if and only if . For any such that , for each we have Therefore the vectors in are linearly independent, implying as desired.