Let be a regular -gon in the plane and be nonnegative integers. It is possible to draw circles so that for each , there are exactly circles that contain on their interior. Find, with proof, the minimum possible value of in terms of the .
Solution
For convenience, we take all indices modulo . Let be the set . Also, let , and . We claim that is the answer. Let be the circumcircle of the polygon. First let's prove that . Obviously . Also, there must be at least circles crossing between and , and a circle can cross at most twice. Thus . We will present two ways to arrive at a construction. Inductive construction. We use induction on . If all the are zero, then the problem is trivial. Now assume that not all the are zero the idea is that we are going to subtract 1 from a consecutive subset of the so that the value of goes down by 1. There are two cases. First of all, if for some , then we can choose such an so that . Then, let be the minimal positive integer so that . Then subtract 1 from . It is clear that decreases by 1. If , then also goes down by 1. If not, then , so goes down by 1 anyway. The second case is when for all . If all the are the same then we are done by subtracting 1 from everything. If not, we can find with so that , and . Then subtract 1 from the complement of . Then goes down by 1 and goes down by 1. Non-inductive construction. We will prove that if , then we may choose . If , then since we can subtract from every , draw circles containing every point, and apply the below construction. Let . Also, let . Note that and that . For and , define an arrangement of circles as follows: let the elements of and be in order. Then for each add a circle covering the points in the interval ]. One can show that point is covered by circles times if and times otherwise. Now, for some choice of for all , consider taking . Then, is covered by circles times. If we choose the so that , which can be shown to be possible, we are done.