Let are distinct primes and . Assume 1 is in . Let be an element of . We define, for all positive integers : How many distinct possible values of are there such that for infinitely many 's?
Solution
If is odd, then we can see by induction that when is even and when is odd (using the fact that no even can divide ). So we have infinitely many 's for which . If is even, then is odd, since , and may have only one factor of 2. Now, in general, let . Suppose . By induction, we have when is odd, and when is even. So for all . It follows that . Then, again using induction, we get for all nonnegative integers that if is even, and if is odd. Clearly, and when is odd (the left side is odd, and the right side even). It follows that for no . Finally, when , we can check inductively that for odd and for even. So our answer is just the number of odd elements in . There are 9 odd prime numbers smaller than 30 , so the answer is .