Maths Olympiad Prep

Track / Stage 2 / 12 of 240 #252 of 2444

Problem 252

Number theory Difficulty 2.1 Prove it CEMC Fryer · Canada · 2012

The prime factorization of 144 is 2×2×2×2×3×32\times2\times2\times2\times3\times3 or 24×322^4\times 3^2. Therefore, 144 is a perfect square because it can be written in the form (22×3)×(22×3)(2^2\times 3)\times(2^2 \times 3).

The prime factorization of 45 is 32×53^2 \times 5. Therefore, 45 is not a perfect square, but 45×545\times 5 is a perfect square, because 45×5=32×52=(3×5)×(3×5)45\times 5 =3^2 \times 5^2 = (3 \times 5)\times(3 \times 5).

Determine the prime factorization of 112.
The product 112×u112\times u is a perfect square. If uu is a positive integer, what is the smallest possible value of uu?
The product 5632×v5632\times v is a perfect square. If vv is a positive integer, what is the smallest possible value of vv?
A perfect cube is an integer that can be written in the form n3n^3, where nn is an integer. For example, 8 is a perfect cube since 8=238=2^3. The product 112×w112\times w is a perfect cube. If ww is a positive integer, what is the smallest possible value of ww?

This one wants a proof. Work it on paper, then read the official solution and mark yourself. Be honest about it: the record is only any use to you if it is.

Next problem →

Official solution

Factoring gives 112=2×56=2×2×28=2×2×2×14=2×2×2×2×7112=2\times56=2\times2\times28=2\times2\times2\times14=2\times2\times2\times2\times7.

So, the prime factorization of 112 is 2×2×2×2×72\times2\times2\times2\times7 or 24×72^4\times7.
For every perfect square, each of its prime factors occurs an even number of times (see the Note at the end of part (d) for a brief explanation of this).

From part (a), the prime factorization of 112 is 24×72^4\times7.

We are asked for the smallest value of the positive integer uu so that 112×u112\times u or 24×7×u2^4\times7\times u is a perfect square.

The prime factor 2 already occurs an even number of times, (four times), in the factorization of 112.

Thus, no additional factors of 2 are needed to make 24×7×u2^4\times7\times u a perfect square.

However, the prime factor 7 occurs only once.

Since all prime factors must occur an even number of times, then at least one additional factor of 7 is needed for 24×7×u2^4\times7\times u to be a perfect square.

Therefore, the smallest positive integer uu that makes the product 112×u112\times u a perfect square, is 7: 112×u=24×7×u=24×7×7=24×72=(22×7)×(22×7).112\times u=2^4\times7\times u=2^4\times7\times 7=2^4\times7^2=(2^2\times 7)\times (2^2\times 7).
Since 5632=512×115632=512\times11 and 512=29512=2^9, then the prime factorization of 5632 is 29×112^9\times11.

Again, every perfect square has each of its prime factors occurring an even number of times.

We are asked for the smallest value of the positive integer vv so that 5632×v5632\times v or 29×11×v2^9\times11\times v is a perfect square.

The prime factor 2 occurs an odd number of times, (nine times), in the factorization of 5632.

Thus, at least one additional factor of 2 is needed to make 29×11×v2^9\times11\times v a perfect square.

The prime factor 11 occurs only once.

Thus, at least one additional factor of 11 is needed for 29×11×v2^9\times11\times v to be a perfect square.

Therefore, the smallest positive integer vv that makes the product 5632×v5632\times v a perfect square, is 2×112\times11 or 22: 5632×v=29×11×v=29×11×2×11=210×112=(25×11)×(25×11).5632\times v=2^9\times11\times v=2^9\times11\times 2\times 11=2^{10}\times11^2=(2^5\times 11)\times(2^5\times 11).
For every perfect cube, the number of times that each of its prime factors occurs is a multiple of 3 (see the Note below for a brief explanation of this).

From part (a), the prime factorization of 112 is 24×72^4\times7.

We are asked for the smallest value of the positive integer ww so that 112×w112\times w or 24×7×w2^4\times7\times w is a perfect cube.

The prime factor 2 occurs four times in the factorization of 112.

Thus, the smallest number of additional factors of 2 needed to make 24×7×w2^4\times7\times w a perfect cube is two (since 6 is the smallest multiple of 3 that is greater than 4).

The prime factor 7 occurs only once.

Thus, the smallest number of additional factors of 7 needed to make 24×7×w2^4\times7\times w a perfect cube is two (since 3 is the smallest multiple of 3 that is greater than 1).

Therefore, the smallest positive integer ww that makes the product 112×w112\times w a perfect cube, is 22×722^2\times 7^2 or 196: 112×w=24×7×w=24×7×22×72=26×73=(22×7)×(22×7)×(22×7).112\times w=2^4\times7\times w=2^4\times7\times 2^2\times 7^2=2^6\times7^3=(2^2\times 7)\times (2^2\times 7)\times (2^2\times 7).

Note: Every positive integer greater than 1 can be written as a unique product of prime numbers (this is known as the Fundamental Theorem of Arithmetic!).

Every perfect square, PP, is the product of a positive integer, nn, with itself.

That is, P=n×nP=n\times n.

By the Fundamental Theorem of Arithmetic, nn can be written as a product of prime numbers.

Since P=n×nP=n\times n, the prime factors of PP are matching pairs of prime factors of nn.

Thus, the prime factors of every perfect square occur an even number of times.

This argument similarly extends to every perfect cube, CC.

Since C=n×n×nC=n\times n\times n for some positive integer nn, then the prime factors of CC occur in sets of three matching prime factors of nn.

Thus for every perfect cube, the number of times that each of the prime factors occurs is a multiple of 3.

Source: CEMC, University of Waterloo, licensed CC-BY-NC-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty, ordering) added by this project.